Reproduction-quilt lovers, are you ready for a decidedly different quilt-block book?
Save your scraps, pile up your precuts, and iron your yardage—The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology is a BIG quilt-block book that will inspire you for years to come!
If you’re like us, you’re “long”ing to stitch these one-of-a-kind rectangular blocks—the unexpected shape is rocking our quilty world!
How did this compendium of rectangular quilt blocks come to be? Coauthors Carol Hopkins (of Civil War Legacies fame) and Linda M. Koenig dreamed up a challenge for their Indiana-based quilt group: design 4″ x 5″ blocks using only reproduction fabrics in blue, black, red, and double pink. That’s what inspired The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology—and the results are breathtaking.
Small Town Parade, pieced by Garnet Roesel and quilted by Lisa Ramsey
At a whopping 208 pages, the book is packed with brand-new block designs—
Clockwise from top left: Ripples, Signature, Log Off, and Apple Seeds
—as well as classic favorites, all reinvented to fit the 4″ x 5″ shape:
Clockwise from top left: Shoo Fly, Hopscotch, Anvil, and Lost Ship
Block photos are so close up, you can see the color and print choices that each quilter made, right down to the teeniest polka dot. And once you’ve made your blocks, you’ll get inspired to set them with examples of magnificent sampler quilts in the gallery. When you buy the book, you’ll get online access to even more settings (trust us, they’re gorgeous).
Did we mention that the anthology also includes ideas for using the blocks in your own quilt group or club? Create a block club just like the authors’ club and have a blast—with this last-a-lifetime book, you’ll never run short of ideas!
We’re thrilled to have Carol Hopkins as a guest writer today, here to tell you the remarkable tale of how the anthology came to be.
But first . . .
FABRIC GIVEAWAY! Carol Hopkins and our friends at Marcus Fabrics curated the American Swatch Book fabric collection—a line of classic prints designed by Judie Rothermel—to pair perfectly with The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology. And we’ve got a bundle to give away to one lucky winner!
Learn how you can win the bundle plus a copy of The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology at the end of this post. (To learn more about American Swatch Book, visit the Marcus Fabrics blog, Marcus Mentions!)
Like many quilters, I count my quilting friends among life’s treasures. Over the last 25 years or so, I’ve been fortunate to share my passion for making small quilt blocks with reproduction fabrics through block exchanges with a special group of friends. Our exchanges focus on creating blocks of a certain size, pattern, or color, such as 3″ multicolored sampler blocks, tiny Shoo Fly blocks in assorted blues, 6″ red-and-green sampler blocks, 4″ pink-and-brown stars, and blocks on which we wrote favorite sayings or quotations.
It Started with a Block-Exchange Idea
When four of us met for lunch a few years ago to discuss our next exchange, we’d just finished a year-long exchange of 96 small Weathervane blocks using only plaids, checks, and stripes. To make our next exchange less time-consuming, we agreed on a simple block consisting of a plain rectangle surrounded by a one-inch border on all sides. Easy enough, until Linda Koenig had an inspiration while driving home, and then sent us a note with an invitation: “Design and assemble 4″ x 5″ quilt blocks using reproduction fabrics in blue, black, red, and double pink. Make four different blocks to share/keep each month, for nine months.” We were hooked when we saw the four sample blocks she enclosed. How hard could this be?
We were hooked and dove into making blocks. But we soon realized the challenge! It’s not hard to design a 4″ block. And it’s not hard to design a 5″ block. But to design a block that’s 4″ in one direction and 5″ in the other? That was trickier, and that’s what made it gratifying.
Blocks from The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology
Linda showed our blocks to another group of her quilting friends, and they decided joined the challenge. In all, we ended up with 182 blocks: some based on adaptations of classic square quilt blocks, and at least 50 new, never-before-seen blocks.
More blocks from The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology
A Book is Born
When I showed the first few months of blocks to the folks at Martingale, they loved the innovative approach and agreed to publish a block book with full-sized photographs and step-by-step cutting and sewing directions for each block, along with a photo gallery of quilts made from the blocks. Thus, the The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology was born.
Sadly, Linda passed away from a devastating illness before the book went to press. She saw the page proofs, but never viewed the book’s beautiful cover featuring her wonderful quilt, the result of a brainstorm on her drive home from lunch. We all greatly miss her friendship and her creative, perfectly pieced quilt designs.
The Sparrow’s Window quilt, pieced by Linda M. Koenig and quilted by Viki Kirby
Next Stop: Fabric
The original 4″ x 5″ blocks were made from a wide assortment of fabrics from the exchange participants’ decades-old stashes. Since there was no existing collection in the marketplace suitable for recreating the 1880s look of the fabrics in the blocks, Jennifer Keltner, Martingale’s Chief Visionary Officer, and I approached Marcus Fabrics about asking Judie Rothermel, one of the pioneer designers of reproduction fabric lines, to create a collection that would capture the color palette and prints used for the blocks in the book.
Marcus Fabrics agreed to develop a new collection, and Judie shared with me approximately 70 fabric swatches of blue, red, pink, black, and shirtings from her private collection of antique textiles. I felt like a kid in a candy store getting to see so many beautiful old fabrics, many of which contained prints never before available to reproduction-fabric lovers. Narrowing the choices to 22 prints was torturous, because, as I’m sure you can imagine, I wanted them all! In the end, the fabric line, which Judie named American Swatch Book, is a collection that beautifully reflects the colors and prints used in the original blocks.
Block-of-the-Month Club
So, what do you do when you have a book of wonderful quilt blocks and a fantastic new fabric line? My response was to create the “It’s Not a Square” Block-of-the-Month Club. The club pairs blocks from the book and the new fabric line to make a 72-block sampler quilt. Available through quilt shops this fall, the club will offer full-color, detailed block guides to create six blocks each month from The 4" x 5″ Quilt Block Anthology using American Swatch Book prints. Information about the fabrics and the club is on its way to local quilt shops now. Watch for the book at your favorite shop, and ask about the club!
What a whirlwind story, Carol—thank you for sharing it with us!
Now, on to the giveaway! For your chance to win the American Swatch Book bundle plus a copy of the The 4" x 5″ Quilt Block Anthology, tell us:
What fabrics would you choose to make the blocks in the anthology?
a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
Tell us your answer in the comments—we’ll choose a random winner one week from today and let you know by email if you win. Good luck! And remember, when you purchase The 4" x 5″ Quilt Block Anthology at ShopMartingale.com, you can instantly download the eBook for free.
Comments are closed for this post.
Thanks to all who entered the drawing! The winner is Connie, who says:
“I love the scrappy look of my collection of reproduction fabrics. I love a challenge of the 4 by 5 blocks. I would love this project.”
We’ll email you about your prize, Connie—congratulations!
I love the fabrics and would like to do the quilt first in those and then perhaps try solids for a modern approach! Thanks!!
—Donna on March 15, 2017Cute concept, love the blocks and fabrics. I think I would pick "B". I would have to add a few zinger fabrics.
—Carol on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises from my stash of reproduction fabrics.
—Jean DeFrances on March 15, 2017I would make my quilt in the original colors as a tribute to Linda M Koenig. What a wonderful looking book-I can’t wait to purchase a copy.
—Sheila S on March 15, 2017I love it!! I would go with b and throw in a few surprises! Beautif!ul
—Pam on March 15, 2017I will definitely be joining in on this fun project! So now to brainstorm on color choices… I’ll choose sashing and border first. Will start with Judie’s lovely new collection but won’t it be hard to resist throwing in some browns and greens?
—Kleg on March 15, 2017Oh it would definitely have to be some repro fabric. The vintage look of the block and the out-of-the square look definitely says make me look warm and yummy. The original fabric selection of black, blue, red and pinks would certainly be a great choice to give the look intended. Love the 4×5 shape!
—Pat Meeks on March 15, 2017I would have to be a ‘C’ have too much rwb already! beautiful book!
—Marian Allen on March 15, 2017I would chose what the original makers intended. I think it is beautiful! I always love Judie Rothermel fabrics.
—Joan Richards on March 15, 2017I would use reproduction fabrics from my stash in the same colors as the original quilt.
—Linda on March 15, 2017Ohhhh..this just sings to me. How,lucky I would be to win!
—Monique MacIntyre on March 15, 2017I can never follow a pattern exactly as shown, so I would probably be a B.
—DebrafromMD on March 15, 2017Can there be an option "D"? I would use my stash and make it scrappy! Love the shape of these blocks. I saw a quilt once made with rectangle shaped drunkard’s path blocks and loved it. This quilt is awesome, too!
—Sandy A in St. Louis on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide and most definitely throw in a few surprises!
—Carolyn Sands on March 15, 2017Exciting book and fabric line! Always love Judie Rothermel fabrics! b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Jan Goppert on March 15, 2017B…. a "few surprises" is always a good plan!
—Sue Flasche on March 15, 2017I would stick with the original style of fabrics but use more than just one collection.
—Diane on March 15, 2017I think these blocks would be great in any fabrics. I’d consider using 30’s reproduction fabrics.
—Karen A on March 15, 2017I think this sampler would look fantastic with a variety of Judie’s fabrics that I have in my stash.
—Liz F. on March 15, 2017Love the book and the fabric! I’d use the same color guide and add from my stash, so I guess that makes me a B. Hoping a local quilt shop will do this program!
—Marilyn O on March 15, 2017B follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Love working with civil war fabrics.
—Kathy Vetter on March 15, 2017I would choose b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I usually love a quilt the way it is shown but I like to make it mine by adding a bit.
—Susan Smith on March 15, 2017Love the idea of 4×5 blocks. I’d have to go with"b". A few surprises would make it my own. Thanks for the give-away.
—Debby on March 15, 2017Can’t wait to get this fabulous book and start sewing right away! I LOVE scrappy so I guess I would lean toward "B".
—Dana on March 15, 2017I would add some purples into the mix.
—Linda Cejnar on March 15, 2017I would probably swap out the blues for another color in my repro stash that meshes well with Judie’s new line.
—Barbara H on March 15, 2017I would use the original color guide (with a few extra Judie Rothermel’s thrown in)
Can’t wait to see the book!! and the fabric!!
—Val on March 15, 2017I think that I would have to honor the originator’s idea first, then if time allows me, do another in my own concept.
—Donna on March 15, 2017The original colors. Love them
—Deborah k on March 15, 2017I would have to do option B. Would have to throw in a few surprises like poisen green or my favorite cheddar. Love the size of these blocks…they are calling my name.
—Debbie Shives on March 15, 2017I love the concept of " not square" blocks! I would follow the colors given but throw in some surprises, especially some purples from my reproductions stash. That would make it my own!
—Ruth Newell on March 15, 2017Absolutely love these patterns and fabric.
—Sherry Chisum on March 15, 2017I would go with option B mainly because I feel better if I have used at least a little something from my stash. LOL
—Jacqueline Leibfried on March 15, 2017Thanks for a chance I think this book and the fabrics are wonderful.
b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Kristine R. on March 15, 2017.I have lots of reproduction fabric. I would try to use the same colors as the patterns and purchase more of these beautiful colors and prints to go with them.
—Sherry Chisum on March 15, 2017Oh, my! I love this book and the fabrics.
—Karen on March 15, 2017I’d add a few of my fabrics in to make it my own.
Thanks for the chance to win!
What talented women! I like the original colorway.
—Gail on March 15, 2017Would love to mix it up a bit with modern colours that pop. Xxx Ness from zzOz
—Ness Spencer on March 15, 2017Probably c, as I would make it from stash and scraps.
—Regina Arlauckas on March 15, 2017I would work with the original design and throw in a few from my collection just to add to the color design.
—Sue Kirk on March 15, 2017Option B! I would follow the color guides but would like to switch it up just to personalize the quilt.
—Ruth R on March 15, 2017I’d use the original colors. Love love love those colors!
—Catherine on March 15, 2017I would follow the color guide but maybe throw in a few surprises.
—Lynda on March 15, 2017As the original maker intended.
—Marsha on March 15, 2017I love traditional Civil War-style fabrics and would probably use them along with a twist or two of my own design!
—Kaaren L. Biggs on March 15, 2017I think I’d do a combination of going with the guide but throwing in some different fabrics to mix things up a bit! Thanks for this wonderful giveaway!
—Susan Mulvihill on March 15, 2017I like the colors and would use the color guide.
—Sonia on March 15, 2017Would go with "B". Follow guide with a few surprises. Love all reproduction fabrics and always love a few surprises.
—Judy Gallman on March 15, 2017I would follow B and throw in some cheddar and purple as it is my favorite color. I really like the rectangular shape and would so use the book and make the quilt…so unusual and adorable.
—Gail T on March 15, 2017I love the original way but I would add a couple of zingers to make it mine.Thanks for a great give away.
—Grams on March 15, 2017I LOVE reproduction fabrics. I have made several quilts using them. I have lots of scraps in the red, brown. black and blue colors. I also have lots of green.
—Judy on March 15, 2017B definitely. I am going to make a Civil War quilt in the near future for my brother. He does Civil War reenactments all over and hope to surprise him with this quilt. So I would put in some fabric of his personal life.
—Sonya Leonard on March 15, 2017C
—Sharon Richins on March 15, 2017I would try to follow the colors but would definitely throw in some zingers, like chrome yellow and cheddar!
—Claire on March 15, 2017A. I prefer traditional and the vintage look. I would want to stay as true to form as possible.
—Mary George on March 15, 2017I would either stay with the original with a few surprises, or replace the double pinks with a peach, orange, or yellow. The fabrics and the pattern are wonderful.
—Eileen on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises to make it my own. Thank you for the chance to win. I love the idea the blocks.
—Diann on March 15, 2017I would use fabrics from my stash.
—Lisa on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Teresa Knittingdancer on March 15, 2017I would choose the original colors
—Rose Anne Henriksen on March 15, 2017I really like the original colorway. Looking forward to seeing all of the fabrics in the line.
—Velva on March 15, 2017I’d go with (a). The book and fabrics are perfect just the way they are.
—Jean McD on March 15, 2017I absolutely love the colors chosen so I would stay with option A and stay with the ones picked for the project. They are beautiful!!
—Carlene Jewett on March 15, 2017I have a "large" cw repro stash. Many leftover from my Dear Jane, some from Jo Morton club, and all our other favorites. I would use all of them. I love the idea of rectangular blocks!!! Gotta have this book. Would love to win it!! And my stash can always use more fabrics. If I win, I would use all of the won fabrics in the new size blocks. Promise!
—Sue Hilton on March 15, 2017I have lots of scraps, I would scrap it with one or two constant colors.
—Diane on March 15, 2017Beautiful book, I love the concept.
b) would be using stash fabrics so it would be scrappy. Love the quilt.
—Dixie on March 15, 2017I would use A), the original fabrics, as I LOVE Civil War repro fabrics and have a few that are looking for a new project. This looks like a fun idea for a block swap and, after getting over the initial "shock" of seeing rectangular blocks instead of square, I have to admit that it looks kinda fun! Thanks for a great giveaway!
—Dottie Macomber on March 15, 2017I would use reproduction fabrics that I have collected and used in the past. I would probably use colors similar to what is shown in the book. I love the challenge of 4 x 5 inch blocks. A great challenge!
—Judy Hunsberger on March 15, 2017My first instinct would be to follow the color guide exactly. That would be copying and I would like to make it my own. So I would begin with the color choices they made, but then add colors. I like scrappy. I could create in a variety of ways.
—Cheryl Zehms on March 15, 2017I would make the quilt with the original fabric colours.
—Maureen Haynes on March 15, 2017A for me, as the quilt looks just perfect the way it is!
—Cathy on March 15, 2017I would use reproduction fabric, it’s my favorite type of fabric to use. My stach is 90% reproduction.
—Gail on March 15, 2017A few surprises to be had, as I have some very old fabric.
b.
—Deb Gordon on March 15, 2017I would follow the original colour guide!
—Deb on March 15, 2017I agree with A. I love a challenge.
—Pat Hoxter on March 15, 2017I’d probably stick with the original colorway and throw in a surprise or two along the way.
—Sandy Navas on March 15, 2017B. I would use calicos and blenders. They seem to be the type I always look for and for this type of quilt would be best in my opinion.
—Anita Duerr on March 15, 2017Love the repro colors but would most likely throw in some modern ones.
—Pamela Wright on March 15, 2017I’d probably have to go "scrappy"
—Virginia Over on March 15, 2017For recreating an 1880’s look, I would go with the original choice of fabrics. That is where the beauty of the time period displays itself. Thank you for this opportunity to be selected as the winning participant!
—Melanie on March 15, 2017I love the rectangular blocks! I think I would choose "B". It’s fun to add some surprises to make the quilt your own.
—Karen Kopp on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises
—Amy Holt on March 15, 2017(b). I would use suggested fabrics but throw in a few surprises.
—Denise Bone on March 15, 2017I would love to make the blocks in modern colors but keeping the scrappy look. I have lots fabrics in my stash to get started, too! Thanks for the great giveaway.
—Audrey on March 15, 2017I would use the original colours with a couple of other colours from my repro stash. Wow! What a fantastic idea! Love it!
—Ondrea on March 15, 2017I love reproductions but I also love new fabric colors! I may have two to make. I’m going to go with: c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
—Robin Hoover on March 15, 2017b. I would definitely throw in some surprises. The whole theme asks for it. Love the ideas and fabrics.
—Becky DuBose on March 15, 2017Wonderful block exchange idea – I’d go with same color choices and a few surprises.
—Saroja on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I’ve gotta use up some other reproduction prints in my stash!! 🙂
—Shannon Wallace on March 15, 2017I would do this quilt in modern fabrics because we have SO MUCH of it! This book will be a terrific addition to our quilt book collection!!
—DeAnna Davis on March 15, 2017I’d definitely do reproduction fabrics much like the ones used. Love that "Old Fashioned Quilt" look. Reminds me of some of my Great Grandmother’s quilts!
—Cindy M on March 15, 2017lstangl482 at aol dot com
I would us mainly the colors used in the book, but throw in a few of my favorites.
—Christine Prager on March 15, 2017I love the colors in the book, but I think I’d throw in a few surprises.
—CJ Hines on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors. I love these blocks.
—Wanda Stephens on March 15, 2017I would use the original style fabrics. I love the reproduction look.
—Mary Beth McKelvey on March 15, 2017I love the reproduction look, but would have to go with "C".
—nancy lewis on March 15, 2017I’d use original style fabrics but different colors. I prefer greens and browns.
—Diana O on March 15, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink. I love this fabric collection and the look of the Civil War quilts.
—Yvonne Allen on March 15, 2017Love the quilt. Will be exciting to try a new concept. Rectangular is my favorite and this now is easier to accomplish. Shirl
—Shirley Handlang on March 15, 2017#1. Go with the original color …I like the grey background
—Betty on March 15, 2017I would use my reproduction stash. That book is very interesting.
—Patricia D. Roberts on March 15, 2017Such decisions! I love the original colors, but might swap out the pink for a coral/salmon, the black for brown, and the blue for soft sage green…keeping the pops of red! Most would be my go-to fabrics – reproductions! Might have to make both colorways, there’s the solution.
—Kathy Oppelt on March 15, 2017I would go with what the original designers intended, blue, red, black and double pink. I love the historical look. Good luck to all.
—Billie Sowers on March 15, 2017Definitly the original colors!
—Jeannette on March 15, 2017I love the original colors and maybe a few surprises!
—Kim H. on March 15, 2017I’m traditional…I’d use the original color plan!
—Linda B on March 15, 2017a). I like yo follow the original intent. It’s so magnificent! What creativity!!
—Vivian Fitzpatrick on March 15, 2017I would probably stay close to the original fabric choices. I love reproduction fabrics and traditional quilts.
—Linda Vargas on March 15, 2017I would make one in reproduction prints using black, green, blues, and poisen yellow. I would also simultaneously make a modern scrap quilt using prints and lots of solids.
—Cynthia B on March 15, 2017Looks like a fabulous book. I would probably add a few colours from my stash.
—Diane H on March 15, 2017I would love to use the fabrics designed for the book, plus a few from my stash that would fit in. Thanks for a new challenge.
—Ann Woodhead on March 15, 2017I like surprises so I think I would add some to this quilt. That way you make it your own.
—Judy A on March 15, 2017I would use the guide in the book, but can’t resist throwing in some of my reproduction fabric that I love..
—Judie on March 15, 2017I love reproduction fabrics. I would use the book as a guide for colors but would probably put in some of my own favorite repro fabrics.
—Sara on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors/patterns fabrics.
—JudyP on March 15, 2017I would choose b. Start with the original colors and throw in a few surprises
—Sharon B on March 15, 2017A) I would use the original colors. I love the look of these reproduction fabrics.
—Christina Phelan on March 15, 2017I would go with the original color scheme.
—Sandy K on March 15, 2017I love the fabric used but I have to go with ‘B’. I couldn’t help but throw in fabrics from my stash.
—Sue Cahill on March 15, 2017A. if I win the bundle; otherwise, C. But, I’ll probably buy Judy’ bundle anyway as she can do no wrong when it comes to fabric lines!
—Kevin B. on March 15, 2017I love the original colorway, I would use those.
—Vicki H on March 15, 2017I would definitely use the original colors as I love reproduction fabrics.
—Kay on March 15, 2017I love the fabrics used and would use the original fabrics. Thanks for the giveaway!
—Linda Edwards on March 15, 2017I would try original first and then on another attempt, through in an embroidery block or two! I am currently working on a patriotic quilt with 9 embroidery blocks that cover the first verse of America The Beautiful!
—Jenn Burwell on March 15, 2017I am a totally A person. if I am making a Civil War quilt, I try to make it as original as possible.
—martha cook on March 15, 2017ooops! "through" meant to be throw!
—Jenn Burwell on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Beautiful quilt!
—Terry on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Sharon on March 15, 2017All my civil war fabrics and a neutral sashing to bring it all together, maybe my collection of 30’s fabrics would work, I could go on and on but so does all the fabric in my sewing room. The book would help with ideas for the 4 by 5 blocks.
—Mary on March 15, 2017I would say A. I really like the original colors they used.
—Susan L. on March 15, 2017I follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—lindamae on March 15, 2017Love the collection as it is, but might have to throw in some cheddar.
—Judy Smith on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colors.
—NancyB on March 15, 2017I would follow the original colors, but would throw in a few surprises for fun!
—Sandra on March 15, 2017Beautiful post! I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
—Janie M on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors !
—Robin Speicher on March 15, 2017I’m not a huge fan of pink, so I would probably do something crazy like replacing it with cheddar! I think this book looks like lots of fun–wish I belonged to such an awesome group of friends that made these blocks!
—Karen in Breezy Point on March 15, 2017I’s using blue, black, red and pinks. I’d also follow the color guide, but I’d use 30’s fabrics. This is so original, I really love it.
—Renee Hanneman on March 15, 2017I would use the original fabrics, I would want something that could become an heirloom.
—Joel Sellers on March 15, 2017I would choose a) but would probably use browns for most of the blacks since I have many more of those
—Barbara Boyd on March 15, 2017Sooo beautiful. Would use original colors, till I run out and then would throw in different colors from my stash. Thank you for wonderful inspiration.
—LindaLee on March 15, 2017Although the pictures made me want to try the original colours, my true love is bright colours so I would have to do the block with modern colours and I am sure the blocks and quilts would still be amazing!
—Vicky on March 15, 2017I would go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink. I love the authenticity of these colours.
—Marg on March 15, 2017I would use a wide variety of colors as well as the Judie rothermel collection
—Judy on March 15, 2017I think I would try using fabrics from my French General stash which also includes blue, black, red and pink. The book looks like a lot of fun!
—Loretta Waterman on March 15, 2017I love the quilt. I would go with the original colors.
—Brenda on March 15, 2017I would do (a). As close to original as possible. Love it.
—Donna Wingo on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors, because I have a lot of those colors in my stash.
—Lesley Rackowski on March 15, 2017I think the quilt is beautiful with the original colors and would probably stick with them. Thanks for the opportunity to win this gorgeous fabric.
—Angela Curtis on March 15, 2017I’d probably do B because I can never leave well enough alone! Love this book and fabric!
Jenny in Florida
—Jenny Brooks on March 15, 2017I would like to try modern fabrics AND throw in as many of these fabrics to add some extra "spice"!!!
—Cindy on March 15, 2017I would use the original.
—Vickie S. on March 15, 2017i would use the original for a guide but probably vary as i go along but I would stay in the same tone quality
—Sue on March 15, 2017I would use similar colors
—Cynthia on March 15, 2017I would use what the original makers intended. I love the civil war quilts and am compiling a collection to be able to make a quilt for my husband.
—Julie Albers on March 15, 2017What a Magic book and gorgious fabrics! I would start a quilt like this… Will I be a lucky girl?? 😍
—Delphine NIBAUDEAU on March 15, 2017c) The option to use brights
—Janna on March 15, 2017I’d choose (a) and make the quilt in the recommended colors…but would probably make a second set of blocks simultaneously in burgundy/green/gold/brown.
—Kathy in WV on March 15, 2017I think I would throw in a few cheddar for pop. Otherwise the book and fabrics are beautiful. Thanks for the chance
—amy f on March 15, 2017I would go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink. I love the small prints they used.
—Dotti Wahlers on March 15, 2017I would choose (b) I love reproduction fabric!
—Beth on March 15, 2017Choices, choices! I think they would all be exciting to try and would definitely make each one look different. I believe though I would choose A to start with. What an interesting concept!
—Kathy H on March 15, 2017I love the combination in choice A. Clever new block design.
—Kris Searle on March 15, 2017Love the different size of the blocks. I would probably use all my retro colors. I have been collecting the Marcus Bros. and Judy’s fabrics for quite a while. Love them all. Looks like a great book!
—Sheri Bennett on March 15, 2017I love the gray background ; it shows off the colors in the quilt without a harsh braziness to the blocks ; with gray: the civil war pinks, browns, burgundy reds, and a mellowed deep purple would show off the design. And I think the gray is the new neutral as well.. the book is a great swap block pattern.
—Theresa on March 15, 2017I tend to use reproduction fabrics for these type of blocks. I love the colors in the bundle!!
—Donna Schalge on March 15, 2017I’d go with modern colors to go with my home’s color palette.
—Kathie L on March 15, 2017I would use the original fabrics and perhaps add a few repro prints of my own. The quilt is stunning and would make a lovely heirloom. Thank you for the opportunity to win your book and the beautiful fabrics.
—Christine Wiseman on March 15, 2017As much as I love the original quilt and fabrics chosen, I’m not good "following orders" and looking the same as everyone else! So I guess I’d have to say c – or at the very least b!
—Susan on March 15, 2017I would probably use fabrics from my stash & make it really scrappy!
—Kathy on March 15, 2017I love Books with tons of block choices! I think my answer would have to be A, B, and C, all 3! This is a book worth doing more than one quilt from….and the cover is stunning….who wouldn’t want one in those colors, and the gray is genius. Then I would have to make a few more!
—Nancy Bart on March 15, 2017I’m not very good at doing what I’m told so, it would definitely be an original quilt. Not modern, exactly, but something unique.
—Nyla-Jean on March 15, 2017I would use reproduction fabrics in all colors, except maybe brown. I would use a little black, but not too often. I love blue and red so they would be predominant.
—Nancy Carlson on March 15, 2017B: I would use the color guide but honestly I would have to add my own twist. Somehow I always have to change something to make it Truely mine.
—Stephanie L. on March 15, 2017I have always loved the idea of rectangblocks. I am a repro lover so I would make the quilt scrappy with many colors.
—Tina Knebel on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. For a long time I have wanted to make a Civil War Era quilt. This would be a great project to do and I’d love to win both the book and the fabric!
—Vicki on March 15, 2017I love this colorway so I would most likely be A and go with the original colors.
—Jody Randall on March 15, 2017I would stay with the reds, white and blues
—Kathy Luehrs on March 15, 2017I would follow the fabric guide of the original makers with probably a few surprises as I have a vast fabric collection.
—Martha Fewell on March 15, 2017I’d make it similar to the model, it seems the older I get the more I have to put my own stamp on a project!
—Judyk on March 15, 2017I would go with a-go with what the original makers intended. I had a Great Great Uncle that fought in the Civil War. He died in the 2nd to the last battle before the end of the war. He wrote quite a few letters while he was in the war that were saved. I have wanted to make a quilt in memoriam of him but have not gotten around to it. This book may make it workable since you can make the quilt in small increments. I would also incorporate some of the letters transferred onto fabric in the quilt as well.
—Bonnie on March 15, 2017A- I would go with the original colors !!!
—Rae Couch on March 15, 2017I’ve been thinking about this book. Love block collections like this. I’d probably dig into my huge scrap pile to make the small block s.
—Darla Zimmer on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors as I love the old school look of quilts.
—Brenda on March 15, 2017Oh I’m more the follow their lead with fabric color choice, but definitely add fabrics from my reproduction collection. I love this idea of Carol and Linda’s and would love to gather my own friend group to make these as a bee each month! Their group sounds so dynamic. Exciting!
—Marie Eddins on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Love having all the blocks available to make the quilt to my own taste. Thanks for the giveaway.
—Rita S on March 15, 2017b.) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. It’s those surprises that would make this quilt my own.
—The Lisa Marie on March 15, 2017I would go with a) original fabrics. I like so much how these turned out. It looks like so much fun to do these blocks. Thanks for the chance at a giveaway.
—Diantha Howard on March 15, 2017I would go with the original palette. If I made a second one, I might use more modern colours.
—Margaret Hynes on March 15, 2017I would use the colors that were used in that time period. Civil War colors and prints to make it like back in that period of our country. The great USA. Love My Country!
—Marilyn on March 15, 2017b it needs a little green
—Judy Smith on March 15, 2017I would probably go with the original guidelines but the mood might strike me to throw in something unexpected.
—Judy on March 15, 2017I would definitely use the reproduction fabrics. I love them. That’s the era my grandmother and grandfather lived in. Thank you so much for an opportunity to win.
—CECILE EMOND on March 15, 2017I’d go with b, but I’d look for some unusual designs to add some surprises.
—Lynn Clogston on March 15, 2017I would start with the original colors and add some of my favorites – greens and browns and a dash of rust.
—Rose Haury on March 15, 2017B. I would use lots of variety in my fabrics to get that scrappy look.
—Lisa Marie on March 15, 2017A. I would use American Swatch Book and go with the original, possibly adding other Judie Rothermel fabrics from my stash. Love the colors!
—Fran on March 15, 2017I would start with the original colors, but probably throw in a few surprises.
—B J Kinney on March 15, 2017I very rarely follow someone else’s design but I would definitely follow the light/dark/mediums within the patterns. And since the blocks are small, it would have to be tiny prints and solids…..
—Darlene on March 15, 2017I would follow the guide but throw in
—Laura on March 15, 2017a few surprises. LOVE the book!!!
Wow! I chose B in a nano second! Love the 4×5 size of the blocks, and this is a quilt that would be challenging but not boring to make, with the variety of blocks. Being one to always avoid a cookie cutter look, throwing in some surprises would make it my own. Love, love, love this and the fabrics are gorgeous!!!!
—Dawn Vereeke on March 15, 2017I would use the same colors as Linda and Carol and use the new fabric line from Judy Rothermel. Love this book and the idea of a BOM so that you have a chance to make these blocks with other people.
—Sheila Kelly on March 15, 2017I love the colors used but think I’d have to add just a few others from my own stash. I love this book and fabric! Thanks for the chance to win.
—Robin McGuire on March 15, 2017C. I probably will use my own colors being careful to follow the tones of the original..
—Debbie Chenoweth on March 15, 2017I would go with the originals–I love 1800 fabrics!
—valerie csmith on March 15, 2017I would probably go with more modern colors. But the quilt on the cover is gorgeous!
—Lani on March 15, 2017I’ve never used many civil war type fabrics, but it would be a fun change. I guess I would go with option "a".
—Winks Krislen Horlings on March 15, 2017I would probably follow the original colors but throw in a few extras from my reproduction fabrics for a little surprise. What a wonderful quilt and the fabrics are beautiful! Thanks for a chance to win!
—Marsha B on March 15, 2017I would use the recommended colors, but throw in fabrics from my own stash too. Then when I finished it would definitely be my own.
—Micky Robinson on March 15, 2017I would have to go with "option A" blue, black, red and double pinks …. my very first quilt was a Civil War inspired quilt for my elderly mother, she was the biggest fan of the epic movie "Gone With the Wind".
—Jody Hogan on March 15, 2017Beautiful quilt as is. I would go with the original colors. What a fun idea.
—Susan on March 15, 2017This looks like my kind of project – can’t wait to see the fabrics. Count me in.
Barbara Cissne
—Barbara Cissne on March 15, 2017B. I’d throw in a few surprise there. I’d probably also use a lot fewer pinks, as pink is my least favorite color.
—Suzanne on March 15, 2017I would go the modern approach. I love elongating blocks in my quilt program to see what they look like.
—Glenda Britten on March 15, 2017I would try ALL of them, A B and C! What fun!
—Wendi M. on March 15, 2017I would go with "B", then add a few of my own surprises from my stash. Thank you for the opportunity to enter this drawing.
—Kaylene Nelson on March 15, 2017I’d be similar to original makers but not use any pink, perhaps adding different hue from my stash or searching for a "perfect" color like a warm golden tone.
—Marty on March 15, 2017I’m not a fan of the grey background, so mine would be a different color..
—Leanne Doty-Idsinga on March 15, 2017Love the new size of block. And all those patterns. What a refreshing look! Thanks for new perspectives.
—Norma Garrett on March 15, 2017I like the original colors but I would be tempted to add a few surprises.
—Jean on March 15, 2017I am pretty sure I would have to try ALL THREE…..
—Donna Wentzel on March 15, 2017I might go with C because I have a lot of batiks that would look interesting in this pattern.
—Susan Stein on March 15, 2017I would make two blocks at a time – one in original colors and one in brights.
—Sharon K on March 15, 2017I’d use Civil War Fabrics, replacing the pinks with cheddar and greens. I appreciate the rectangular blocks in place of squares.
—EllenB on March 15, 2017I’d go with b), I love repro fabrics and am so excited to see the new line, but I may throw in some other colours as well.
This looks like such an awesome book and I really hope I win! Thanks for the wonderful giveaway and opportunity to win!
—susan on March 15, 2017I would use the reproduction colors and throw in a few surprises. Love this book, and the story behind it!
—Dixie on March 15, 2017My approach would be a B. I would honor the color guide, but do it by adding in brown and leaving out the blue. Carol, thank you for the inspiring book!
—Jan on March 15, 2017I would go with civil war fabrics in muted colors with a little less dark than shown. I love these designs and would consider making the one with signatures as a wedding quilt for a grandchild.
—Nancy Gerdes on March 15, 2017A. How could you change an already awesome quilt?
—Brenda Hulsey on March 15, 2017I would use the original quilt colors from the pack and throw in some from my stash if the blended with the pack.
—Jean Greene on March 15, 2017I would use C as I tend to bounce around all styles and to me this just calls for modern.
—Rina on March 15, 2017B) I would follow the color way but add a few of my own!
—Cindy Rekow on March 15, 2017I would be an "A" and use the original colors. Why mess with a good thing!
—Karen DH on March 15, 2017I would probably choose A, since I already have many of those colors and textures.
—Pat Meinecke on March 15, 2017I would piece the quilt in the colors shown. Although I like the idea of a two color quilt for this pattern. I definitely would make a couple of them first to see if I like it before delving into the whole project.
—JaniceCarole on March 15, 2017A. I love the Civil War era fabrics! This is a definite must do!!!
—Joan on March 15, 2017I would go with answer B. Some of my favorites from my stash would wiggle their way into the quilt.
—Charlotte Schindler on March 15, 2017I would like to do all three options but would do (a) first. Go with what the original makers intended. Thank you for this opportunity.
—Janey Cook on March 15, 2017I would use mostly original but throw in some more grey and pink. I love the blocks.
—Inger on March 15, 2017I would use mostly traditional choices but throw in some extras, like yellow, to brighten it up.
—Pat on March 15, 2017The cover quilt is gorgeous – perfect colors for these blocks. I would go with the colors the original makers selected: blue, black, red, and double pink. Beautiful colors that have been reproduced.
—carol on March 15, 2017I’d stick with the collection. It’s absolutely beautiful!
—Tamara Larson on March 15, 2017B) I’d follow the color guide, but throw in a few surprises. I can’t wait to see the book!
—Barbara on March 15, 2017I’d use the template, but throw a little of my own style in there, so B.
—Ann Muth on March 15, 2017I would use 1930’s fabrics. I have quite an obsession with the flour sack reproduction as well and think this would be lovely to use for this fresh, new idea!
—Keta on March 15, 2017A, I’d go with the original.
—Kathi Ernst on March 15, 2017B. I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Love the variety of block patterns. Would love to win a copy of the book.
—Rickie on March 15, 2017I love the original quilt. Don’t think I could do better. Adore Judy Rothermel’s fabrics. The Anthology book is inspiring, what fun doing rectangle blocks – we all need a change.
—lynn jarzombeck on March 15, 2017I would go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red and double pink. I usually feel the original makers have the best ideas.
—Lin H on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Linda Ferguson on March 15, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
I can not wait to start, even if I do not win the fabric or the book.
—Julie Craven on March 15, 2017B
—Teri Long on March 15, 2017I would try to stick with the colors in the book. They look great together! Can’t wait together this book!
—Rhonda K on March 15, 2017I would go with C…definitely C. I’m more of a bright spectrum quilter.
—Cindy on March 15, 2017I’d have to go with #1, the original colors. Just love it!
—Carol Gearey on March 15, 2017I choose choice ‘b’ because as much as I love using the traditional colors, I like making quilts with a bit of my flair! The quilt has to reflect a bit of my personality.
—Diane Richardson on March 15, 2017My choice is B.
I’m not a fan of pinks – so I’d choose some other colors. Thanks for opportunity to win such a nice gift!
—sonja on March 15, 2017Been looking forward to making a Civil war era quilt with those blacks, reds, blues and especially double pinks that add a spark. The patterns give a more contemporary look but do not take away from the classic feel. Would love to start mine with your selection blended into what I have already collected.
—Patty Daurizio on March 15, 2017I would love to win this wonderful new book and fabric bundle. I would use the original colors they chose. Thanks for the giveaway – I sure hope to win! 🙂
—Sheila Fernkopf on March 15, 2017go with the originals but throw a few surprises for fun
—Joyce on March 15, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended:blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Kathy Railsback on March 15, 2017Love , love, especially the off centered rows…thanks!
I would go with the civil war fabrics mentioned to recreate this fabulous quilt.
—Frances Claassens on March 15, 2017How fun, 4×5 blocks!! New yet old, love it!! I would stay very close to the original fabrics that were used but I have some stash that I would incorporate as well!!
—Carrie Ramnes on March 15, 2017A. Maybe a little bit of B.
—Janet Fletcher on March 15, 2017I would choose A. The blocks already look fabulous!
—Susan Stanton on March 15, 2017The red, black, navy and double pink color scheme is so attractive that I may stick with it. But I really love green, so I may throw in a few forest and poison greens just to keep things interesting.
—C. Delostrinos on March 15, 2017I would go with the fabrics and throw in a surprise…or three!
—susan on March 15, 2017Ah – the color guide and a few surprises. I’ve never exactly followed the rules, you see!!
—Marilyn Rose on March 15, 2017I would definitely use the the original intended colors, but I have such a large stash of civil war reproduction fabrics that I would have to throw in a few more colors. What a great project!!!
—Patty Kehoe on March 15, 2017B. I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few suprises!
—Kerry Coburn on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I like changing some fabrics to add my own touch.
—linda duree on March 15, 2017C. I would use modern fabrics, or maybe batiks and maybe enlarge some of the blocks.
—Jill on March 15, 2017I’d probably throw in a few surprises!
—Pat on March 15, 2017I would use the reproduction fabrics,and may add a few surprises. This book looks fabulous- love the idea and challenge of making 4X5″ blocks. It’s not surprising when a group of quilters get together to challenge themselves in a new direction that such creativity flows out!
—carol on March 15, 2017I’d go with the original colors used. That makes it a more original quilt in my book. Loves those combinations and love making historical quilts.
—Eileen Moss on March 15, 2017I will use modern fabrics, of course! I like new challenge with new fabric
—Maria Magdalena on March 15, 2017This book is awesome! I would use the colors suggested.
—Kim on March 15, 2017Definitely colors with surprises…Just love surprises!
—Karen Keeler on March 15, 2017I love so many of the quilt blocks and the overall look of the quilt and would not want to change much in the way of the color scheme, if at all. The story behind the quilt lends itself to adhering to its designer’s purpose and the character of the quilt.
-Carol on March 15, 2017
—Carol on March 15, 2017I feel that I probably would use the original colorway, using only civil war reproduction fabrics.
—Annette F. on March 15, 2017I think (b) would be my approach – original colours plus a surprise or two. I find it interesting that the blocks are not square. How many girls tell you that they don’t like math..we should teach them to quilt at a very early age!
—Gail G on March 15, 2017I would use most of the colors but throw in s few others. I would love to win these fabrics!
—Denise Cabral on March 15, 2017Wow, my hands started itching just looking at these quilt blocks. I’d like to use the original colours first but trying out different colour schemes later.
—Hedda Boon on March 15, 2017Oh my, the repo fabrics are wonderful. Would have to use the repos and maybe add in a few more colors. Love the Sparrow’s Window quilt.
—Debbie on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I think it would look great in modern colors too.
—Deb G. in VA on March 15, 2017B-I would add some green and yellow and maybe a bit of applique.
—Andrea on March 15, 2017What a choice to make and what a fantastic idea — love the new approach to blocks and I would probably toss a coin as to what fabrics I would choose. My instinct is to go with "b" — using repro, but adding my own "surprise" fabric. Thanks for the continuing inspiration — so many ideas, so little time! 🙂
—Carol Schon on March 15, 2017I would stay with the original fabrics and the new collection. I just love this quilt!!
—Freda on March 15, 2017Great quilt designs and fabric colors for my two sons who have been asking me to find a design that they would like and this is it.
—Cathleen Joyce on March 15, 2017I would use modern colors. The civil war colors are sad.
—Liz ADams on March 15, 2017I woild definitely choose the original colors; those are the colors I’m always pulled to when choosing fabric for my next quilt!!
—Kaye Phipps on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors, maybe add a few from my stash. What a wonderful book!
—Susie Miller on March 15, 2017I would stay true to the concept of the book and use the original colors.
—Kathy on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide and add Ina few colors for a surprise!
—Stacy Thomas on March 15, 2017I think I’d go with the original maker’s colors but throw in some surprises. Maybe some dark green?
—Diana Steverson on March 15, 2017I would use it as a scrap quilt in a variety of fabrics
—Karen on March 15, 2017"b" would be my choice.
—AS on March 15, 2017I’d use the original colors, but might shop my stash for other fabrics and do a second one (or two, or three……..)
—Fran R on March 15, 2017I would work from my own stash of reproductions.
—Mary Oddan on March 15, 2017I’d go with the traditional colors as originally intended. Traditional colors are hard to pinpoint timewise, so therefore, if it takes you years to do then you haven’t indicated what year you started and what year you finished. Why give away secrets? lol.
—mary elen on March 15, 2017I’d use a mix of fabrics…the line designed for the blocks with some of my stash thrown in for fun! (Not to mention reducing my stash!). Love the book and the fabric!
—Sharon Linders on March 15, 2017Would love to make this quilt in fabrics pictured, but if I’m using my stash, I think I’d try solids!
—Pat V. on March 15, 2017Oh my…it is so hard to choose. I love the reproduction fabrics and also think the quilt blocks would be wonderful in nice bights of today. I definitely will look forward to buying the book when it is released.
—Sharron Meyer on March 15, 2017This book looks so intriguing! I would love to try this project. I would use the recommended colors, with a few additions.
—Brenda on March 15, 2017What a glorious quilt! Probably the original colors. But, it might depend on who is to be the recipient of the quilt — or in which room the quilt will reside.
—Linda S. on March 15, 2017I think I’d use A. Traditional colors make the quilt.
—Chris Rose on March 15, 2017I would follow the colors in the book as closely as I could. They are perfect!
—Nell on March 15, 2017Option B, I love the colors, but would include my own fabrics!
—Pam Doerge on March 15, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Tammy on March 15, 2017I tend to follow the pattern pictures because I have a hard time sometimes going outside of the box
Hard to decide. I would use reproduction fabrics but not necessarily what was originally used. Fun challenge!
—Pam Losely on March 15, 2017I love the original color scheme, but I would make it in Civil War repro scraps, and open the blocks up to many more traditional colors.
—Elizabeth McDonald on March 15, 2017I’m torn, if I won the bundle it would be decided! Otherwise I would shop my stash and try to stay in the blue, black, red and double pink theme. It’s always a crap shoot when designing though.
—Elaine Chamberlain on March 15, 2017I’d love to try with modern fabrics for a new look.
—Betsy on March 15, 2017Oh my stars! What a beautiful gift was Linda Koenig! I would very much wish to honor her vision, and it feels like I could have been her friend too!This quilt will be an absolute joy to put together! Perhaps my friends would also see the purpose…one that leads to joy!!!!!
—Margaret Dietl on March 15, 2017Oh my! I love repro fabrics so I would go with the original. I love these patterns. What a great prize.
—Jocelyn on March 15, 2017I’d go with traditional colors and add a few from my stash; thus making the quilt that has my input as well.
—Kathleen Sheridan on March 15, 2017I would go with, B. Follow the guild, but through in some surprises.
—Marilynn on March 15, 2017a, love the colors! especially the Window one, with the lighter blue gray borders.
—Sharon Schipper on March 15, 2017Did anyone notice in 7 Brides for 7 Brothers how the quilts started showing up as skirts on those women? good answer to how she clothed them when they arrived with nothing! historically in Oregon those should have been mid 19th century patterns. I guess I see quilts everywhere in movies now. Love our hobby: we give joy to our friends and family, we contribute to a long history, what’s not to love!
sharon in colorado
Option B. I love the colors but would throw in a pop of yellow.
—Melissa E on March 15, 2017I would do the Quilt in the original colours. I am a person if a like what I see I have a hard time changing colours.
—Sandy Dagg on March 15, 2017I’d love to try these in modern fabrics, even solids, but I’m not a one facetted person, I love the original as well!!!
—Diane Nagle on March 15, 2017The reproduction fabrics are so lovely, I would definitely go with these😀
—Carol Jiles-Davis on March 15, 2017I would use what they used and throw in a few surprises of my own. But wouldnt it be a fantastic idea to pair up with a modern quilter and have them make the same blocks you are but with a modern twist. Call it the modern civil war quilt. Both would be a lot of fun!
—Sue in Kalamazoo on March 15, 2017I would use modern, bright colors. Thank you for this chance to win this book and fabric stash.
—Virgi on March 15, 2017Oh, my goodness! I would definetly go with the original colors. They are so perfect for this quilt. I would try to use scraps from my stash, as I do have so many of these. But, it would really make me happy to win this wonderful fabric bundle. Thanks for the chance to win! This would really be enjoyable to make, and cherish as a personal reminder of my time spent living in Indiana. Godspeed to those who also find a connection with this quilt.
—Diane Dunder on March 15, 2017What a beautiful quilt! I have been wanting to start a reproduction quilt and this is a great motivator. I would use the original colors–they are stunning.
—Linda on March 15, 2017The fabrics are nice. Myself I would go for the modern twist and try the blocks also in more modern fabrics.
—Tamara Isaacs-Smith on March 15, 2017I’d follow the colors from the book, as they are gorgeous! Normally, I would throw in a few surprises, but why mess with perfection?
—Christine E. on March 15, 2017I choose a and I need these fabrics. Thank Thank you Daniela
—daniela on March 15, 2017My choice would be (a).
—Mary on March 15, 2017I would follow the color guide but would add a few of my own stash pieces to make it "mine".
—Joan H. on March 15, 2017I would choose option B….as I may have a few colors in the stash bin that would work well for these patterns.
—Joanne Larson on March 15, 2017Thank you!
I would probably use similar fabrics to theirs, but I love purple so I would add some of that, too.
—Barb on March 15, 2017Option B
—Joyce Ann on March 15, 2017I would go with reproduction fabrics. Love the blocks.
—Joanne Wilson on March 15, 2017Wow!!!!!! This is my kind of guilt—–Love the book–I would pick B
—Bea Donald on March 15, 2017Have to say Wow Again
I’d have to go with B … adding in a few surprises from my CW fabrics. Looks like a wonderful book and bundle, would love to sew it up! Thanks for the giveaway!
—TXQuilter on March 15, 2017Can I make two? 😉 One on the original colors and one on bright yellows and oranges, reds and black. I LOVE the idea of rectangular blocks, by the way!
—Rubí Wood on March 15, 2017I would follow but throw in a few surprises to make it mine…
—Carolyn on March 15, 2017Thank you for sharing this…love it…
A B C and D! I’d love a tonal version as well.
—Kitten WAW on March 15, 2017I would go traditional! (A) I love this book and the fabrics are gorgeous!I absolutely relish the written books!! Thank you !!
—Jeri Hernandez on March 15, 2017I would follow the guide first time around but I think that I would also like to put my own spin on it on a second one.
—Debbie Hastings on March 15, 2017(a)I’d use the original designers intended choices! Thank You for a Great Giveaway> a Great Book+a Great Bundle!!!
—LINDA on March 15, 2017I would love to see these blocks in new, modern prints so Option C. I always have to throw in a few black & whites.
—KristinLaura on March 15, 2017B- I’d probably use the fabrics in the book with some additions. Red and white is a possibility too.
—Jill on March 15, 2017"A" for sure I’d use the new color line, I love them and the idea of not a square, 4×5 blocks.
—Pat Wagle on March 15, 2017I’m a traditional girl, I would go with A.
—Laura Greig on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors, with a few surprises from a coordinated reproduction fabric in my stash. Love the period pieces.
—Sandra Rosier on March 15, 2017I’d go for A, the original. I just love the look of that quilt
—Debby Thompson on March 15, 2017I think I’d probably try option "C". I love to make traditional blocks using modern fabrics and this one could be stunning.
—Kay Taylor on March 15, 2017Love the quilt as shown. I would choose A.
—Jan Horn on March 15, 2017I would love to make this quilt, and I’d try doing it in the original makers intended colors….I think. I really like the way those colors in the quilt on the cover of the book make me feel. Very comforting. Thanks for the inspiration!
—Kathy Swanson on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Thank you for the giveaway – they are so much fun
—Martha Morgan on March 15, 2017I would have to go with option B. Love the original but there needs to be a few standouts scattered throughout.
—Ann Matheny on March 15, 2017I would use repro fabrics in blues, browns, indigo and creams
—Cheryl Hence on March 15, 2017I would go with the original makers and throw in some cool reproductions.
—Crystal on March 15, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended. Being 77 years young, I’m all for preserving the past and reminding the younger quilters of the beauty of our grandmothers and great grandmothers work.
—Judy on March 15, 2017I would go with "C" I love trying different color fabric and see how they go together.
—Diane Steiger on March 15, 2017I would try to follow the colors but maybe throw in a "surprise" fabric that wouldn’t be expected but would still fit in.
—Kathy Osterby on March 15, 2017I think that I would go with "C". These blocks are so adorable, that I think any color combination would work!
—Barbara Johnson on March 15, 2017I love the blue, black, red and double pink !
—Lois Capper on March 15, 2017Probably B – follow most of the colors, but add a few other repros in too.
—Kathy M. on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Sherril McGann on March 15, 2017I love these blocks and would love to make the quilt in the beautiful reproductions, THEN I would love to make a modern version. Lots of love here!
—Susan Reynolds on March 15, 2017I would create the blocks in the original colors so that the quilts would go with my Hitchcock furniture.
—Sheila Civale on March 15, 2017c) I have a lot of B&C and Fig Tree fabrics in my stash and every quilt looks great with them!
—Hildy on March 15, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few suprises. Love these blocks.
—Debra A Ludlow on March 15, 2017I would first make it with repro fabtics which are my favorites.
—Helen Young on March 15, 2017I’m glad there’s a new book and new line of fabrics from Judy.
I would use the fabrics the fabrics suggested, but also include a few from my stash. I love the colors of civil war repos. They are soothing.
—Pam Combs on March 15, 2017Choosing fabric for a quilt is the hardest part of the process for me, so I’m an "A" 🙂
—Dawn Hollingsworth on March 15, 2017A – The original. That would be a new color scheme for me.
—Karen on March 15, 2017I would mostly go what the original makers intended, but probably replacing the pinks with reproduction greens. Thanks for the chance to win!
—Karen N on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colors, I think it helps link us to the past.
—Deborah B. on March 15, 2017Hi, I would go with the original colors the makers intended as I am partial to these colors.
—Marion on March 15, 2017I follow patterns as I know my quilts will come out as they should.
I have a hard time coordinating colors so when I buy bundles I know all my fabrics will match.
Marion
I usually use the book colors as a guide but sometime is strike off on my own! Beautiful book and fabrics!
—Ellie on March 15, 2017I would pick group A
—Janet Lehman on March 15, 2017I would definitely go with the original makers intended colors…gorgeous!
—Angelia L. on March 15, 2017I would use 30’s prints and solids. I have a love of that era fabric. Thank you for the contest.
—LeAnn on March 15, 2017I would like to go with what the original makers intended but I would also like to use some fabrics from my stash so I would probably throw in a few others.
—Kalen Hahn on March 15, 2017I love the colorway chosen for this quilt and if lucky enough to win I know that is the colorway I will be using.
—Irene Cole on March 15, 2017I am all about traditional and reproduction fabrics. The only time I use moderns is when I’m sewing a gift for someone else.
—Leslie B Campbell on March 15, 2017This is such a great idea – I love the rectangular blocks so much!! I would use the original colors, I think – I’ve only made one other Civil War repro prints quilt, and this one would be a delight, also!
Thanks for the chance!
—Elizabeth Bolton on March 15, 2017Option A. I would use traditional colors!!
—Karen Bergt on March 15, 2017I’d go with the original makers colors: blue, black, red and double pink; I like them and probably wouldn’t have chosen them myself.
—Michele on March 15, 2017Probably B, because I like surprises!
—Alice Barthe on March 15, 2017I love the Rothermel collection designed for use with this book and would use it to make a lap quilt using favorite blocks from the book, but my next big quilt needs to incorporate my Oriental fabric stash. These elongated blocks remind me of the asymmetry you often see in Asian quilts – can’t wait to see the book!
—Susan Putman on March 15, 2017I would go with (A)blue, red, black and double pink, I absolutely love the quilts shown from the book and would want to replicate it – I have developed a thing for civil war fabrics
—Kim Britton on March 15, 2017I love the reproduction fabrics and I would use them and anything in my stash that fit well with them.
—Carole Plourde on March 15, 2017*C* I have a LOT of fabric but mostly Blues and Greens. very little Pink and Black.BUT If I had the reproduction fabrics I would follow the colours pictures.
—elizajane on March 15, 2017I would follow the color guide but I would throw in some surprises ! I think the 4 by 5 inch blocks could be used in so many different projects !
—Nancy C on March 15, 2017I would love to win, thanks for the giveaway !!
While the traditional colors are nice I think I would use brights, os I pick option C
—Judy Repp on March 15, 2017I’d go with a and use the fabrics the authors chose
—stephanie woodward on March 15, 2017I would choose b. I would use the suggested fabrics but mix in some of my own where possible.
—Louise King on March 15, 2017I would probably use more modern fabrics, depending on whom the quilt was going to. I do like the subdued colors,but they aren’t me!
—janet g on March 15, 2017Option C, I love Modern!
—Margaret Dalmer on March 15, 2017I would use civil war and reproduction fabric. Trying to get close to color block.
—Lorie Bugaiski on March 15, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink. I love the old look…probably because I grew up with them.
—Rebecca Pobanz on March 15, 2017Oh the infinity of possibilities! I would likely substitute deep brown for the black since that the way I collected my CW fabrics. I don’t think I have any maroon in my stash, but I probably have cranberry.
—Nancilyn on March 15, 2017I would pick "b", and use some of my stash which would coordinate with the civil war theme. Linda was quite talented and ambitious as learned from her obituary! Thanks for the opportunity to win such beautiful prizes.
—jean howard on March 15, 2017I would try this in modern fabrics, probably batiks in MANY colors (scrap-buster?).
—lynn on March 15, 2017A. I’d go with the originals. And I love, love the new line of fabrics. I’d buy every one of them
—Kathy M on March 15, 2017I love the patterns and fabrics in civil war quilts and would stay true to the era.
—Debbie Littrell on March 15, 2017I’d primarily go with the original colors, but would be unable to resist a few surprises.
—Donna on March 15, 2017My answer is "A". Don’t mess with a good thing.
—Carolyn Temple on March 15, 2017I like the original colors, but I might be tempted to do another in bright new fabrics too.
—Cynthia Sato on March 15, 2017I would go with reproduction fabrics in a varied color palette.
—Carolyn Hurst on March 15, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink. Civil war fabrics are my passion.
—Rosemary on March 15, 2017I love history and would choose the original color suggestions.
—Karen Friederich on March 15, 2017What a great book! Also love the "swatch fabrics". I would start with the book’s choice of colors for the blocks choice "a". Seems like you could just go crazy and do so many different quilts with the blocks offered — I would love to do a signature quilt with my friends signing the blocks. Thanks, Jan
—Jan Dudley on March 15, 2017B – I rarily follow directions exactly as printed. Like to throw in something different.
—Linda Ahn on March 15, 2017C. I would probably use from my stash.
—June on March 15, 2017I love Civil War prints. I would go with the original colors.
—Shelor on March 15, 2017A) Yo iría con lo que los fabricantes originales pretendían: azul, negro, rojo y rosa doble. Es un libro fantástico, maravilloso. Los bloques son preciosos. Ojalá que me toque!
—Margarita on March 15, 2017Translation: A) I would go with what the original designers intended: blue, black, red and double pink. It’s a fantastic, wonderful book. The blocks are beautiful. I hope you pick me!
I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. Love love love your choices!
—Michele Cais on March 15, 2017I would go with the authors choices. I do have a few in those colors to add to that stash. I think it would go nicely with my 1876 blue and white Ocean Waves,don’t you?!
—Kathy G on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises in bright new fabrics
—MONICA DE ALBA on March 15, 2017My answer is "A". I love the original colors. I love the civil war fabrics!
—Jeanette Jensen on March 15, 2017B. I would have to replace the double pink with cheddar yellow. I have a fairly good collection of reproduction fabrics. I would love to win this prize. Thanks for the great giveaway. Churn dash is my favorite block.
—Liz Dyer on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colors as they are shown but I have a large amount of scraps and yardage from Civil War fabrics that I might want to use.
—Sally Leu on March 15, 2017I think the original choice would be for me. Blue is my favorite
—Edna Meads on March 15, 2017color, but I also like the red and black quilts I have seen.
I pick C, I like to really mix old and new🔡
—Judy Thompson on March 15, 2017I would go with b and maybe add a few to make it unique.
—Nina on March 15, 2017B is my choice but would have to add a bit of yellow and green.
—Joane on March 15, 2017Luv your story energies and talents you share. I will have to ask for mom’s day present to get this treasure if not the very lucky winner.
I’d chose "A". They are beautiful fabrics and would make a wonderful quilt.
—Sharron on March 15, 2017Id use the same fabrics as the book with some extras thrown in, especially cheddar.
—Catherine Kelleher on March 15, 2017All my life (72 years) I have heard of Richard Dawson Goodwin. He was my great, great, great grandfather and also President Lincoln’s first "life guard". He organized the regiment and persuaded Congress that the President needed life guards as he was being shot at while riding his horse. Of course the period he lived in indicates the reason I mention this. Reproduction fabrics have always been my favorite and I always think of him and his persistence when I look at them. If I were to win I would choose b.)follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I would love to make all of those 4″ x 5″ blocks and challenge my friends to do the same!
—Kathleen Gunning on March 15, 2017I would add a few additional pieces to the collection ‘The Swatch Book’. I think a few more shirting would be a nice touch.
—Phyllis Richard on March 15, 2017) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Cheryl Marande on March 15, 2017I could go with a,b or c. It depends on who I was making the quilt for. Thank you for making this available.
—Chris on March 15, 2017c) I’d make them with modern fabrics.
—Laura on March 15, 2017I would choose "B" so I could use some of my fabrics and create a quilt that would be a "fit" for our home. Thank you for sharing the history behind the book and fabric and for offering the book and fabrics as a giveaway. I’d love to add this color way to my stash!
—Billie Carter on March 15, 2017b) – I’d follow the the originals, but may use a few coordinated surprises as well.
—Judy on March 15, 2017I would go with choice A, but maybe add one or two other colors of reproduction fabrics. I can’t wait to see the book!
—Sara Reynolds on March 15, 2017love the reproduction look. I would use a touch more red.
—Sheila on March 15, 2017B is what I would do.
—Karen H on March 15, 2017I wish I had this fabric line for a project I recently finished. They are from the correct time period for the quilt I made.
for the not squares in the quilt, I would use the colors in the fabric line, but add a couple of other, period appropriate colors
—Laura Lane on March 15, 2017a- I would go with what the original makers intended with blue, black, red, and pink.
—Nancy Harvey on March 15, 2017I would do this in modern colors with a mixture of traditional colors.
—Caroline J Rohrer on March 15, 2017I would go with "B" but add some stand out reproduction prints. I love a quilt that has a big wow of color to catch the eye. I really like civil war reproduction prints.
—Sharon Cirillo on March 15, 2017The original colors are so fitting for the blocks. Makes an old antique & elegant look.
—Anna Hutchins on March 15, 2017I pick ‘a’ and go with the original colors.
—Judy Allen on March 15, 2017I have a fat quarter reproduction bundle I’d love to use for a quilt. I’d go with B. Thanks for the giveaway.
—Barbara on March 15, 2017I love the blocks shown on the book cover!! I would choose (b) to start using the original plan but one does have to be creative and change things up a little. I love the fabric line shown, beautiful.
—Coralie Wallace on March 15, 2017I would go with original fabrics selected but think quilt blocks would look very pretty in a variety of other fabrics and colors.
—Joyce C on March 15, 2017I would probably be right in the middle at B.
—Janice Mc Laren on March 15, 2017Tough choice but my first inclination looking at the pictures would be scrap quilt with my modern scraps so c is my choice but love the repo fabrics too
—denise bromberg on March 15, 2017Hello- I would go with "A" the the designers original fabric choices. It says retro Civil War to me. The thought of Rectangle blocks would be such a great quilt, I have a very tall wall I hang my quilts on and this quilt would be a "Show Stopper" in our living room! Here’s to hoping I win a copy of this great book! Thanks for chance!
—Crystal Nichols on March 15, 2017I would go original!
—Cindy Weeks on March 15, 2017I would go with the original color scheme to make these wonderful blocks.
—Janet Beyea on March 15, 2017I would use the original color scheme.
—Donna McDaniel on March 15, 2017Love this quilt. I would go with be, the surprises being not so much pink, maybe some purple, green, and possibly so shades of gold.
—Jo on March 15, 2017Ta beautiful give a way Would love to make it in the civil war color range Keeping my fingers crossed.
—Bea langeweg on March 15, 2017Would try to stay with A but occasionally throw in a B. These look like such fun blocks. My Civil War Sewing Group would have a ball with these.
—connie b on March 15, 2017Choice B. Mix in a few surprises, I own a large stash of reproductions. I LOVE this book!
—Mary jones on March 15, 2017So inspiring and so wonderful an opportunity. Thanks
—Dorothy Davis on March 15, 2017I’d go with "A" because I learned something new! "Double pink" is a color that I’d never heard of before. I recently inherited some very old quilts and one had a color of sashing that I’d never seen before. It’s double pink!
Thanks for the opportunity!
—Jetta on March 15, 2017Oh, how gorgeous! I LOVE Civil War Fabrics, and am debating between choice a & b. I guess I’d go with b–love the idea of making it my own, but sticking to the original!! Thanks for the chance…fingers are crossed!
—Heathquilter on March 15, 2017What a wonderfully innovative block exchange—easy for beginners but something for the advanced quilter. I would have to pick B as it will be hard to stick to the original color scheme without throwing in something unexpected and fun!
—Kathy on March 15, 2017I’d do B.
—Kathleen on March 15, 2017I love the old quilts from the 19th Century and their wonderful fabrics. It would be fun to use those with a few zingers thrown in, making it a sort of ‘grown-ups’ I Spy quilt.
—Barbara Nevaril on March 15, 2017I would stay with the original colors because I’ve not done a reproduction/Civil War colored/themed quilt and it’s on my list to do.
—Susan M on March 15, 2017C….new, modern design would be a fun surprise.
—Colleen on March 15, 2017B. Mostly the original colors, but a few extras thrown in.
—Mary Lou on March 15, 2017I love the rectangular size of the blocks! I like the A colors, but think B is more my style.
—Evelyn Haupert on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Susan N. on March 15, 2017Would love to make this quilt in Black, white, red, and all shades of gray so (c) is my choice
—Shirley Symns on March 15, 2017I’d throw in a couple surprises — I always find something in my stash that seem to "just fit". Hope I win!
—Carol Vickers on March 15, 2017I love the original colours and would do that first and then experiment with other combinations.
—Linda on March 15, 2017I would choose `a` for the quilt,then look at my stash to use one or two blocks for a different quilt. Many ideas are coming to me as I write. The fabric`s are beautiful. This book would be one I would add to my bookshelf ready yo use at any time.
—Clare Campbell on March 15, 2017Probably do my own thing 🙂
—brenda stone on March 15, 2017I’d definitely go with what the original makers intended. I just love the colours and designs of the fabrics picked by Judie Rothermel
—Lee on March 15, 2017I’d go with B by subbing in other colors than pinks. What a great giveaway! Thanks!!
—Janet L. on March 15, 2017I would use my repro stash. Love those civil war fabrics!
—Susan norrell on March 15, 2017b. I’d follow the color guide, but throw in a few surprises.
—Jill Hicks on March 15, 2017C- amo i colori e le fantasie moderne
Translation: C- I love the colors and the modern fantasies
—Federica pibia on March 15, 2017I’d go with choice (a) as have never liked the thought of pink and red together but these fabrics and the block photos have definitely changed my mind. My fingers are tightly crossed.
—Trish P. on March 15, 2017A
—nadia on March 15, 2017The original, I’m a traditional kind of person
—Rho on March 15, 2017A. I’d go with what the designers intended. In fact I’m doing a red-white-blue sampler right now, but I think of it as cranberry-cream-denim and hope it will look aged when it is done.
—Sherry Jurykovsky on March 15, 2017I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics – the quilts would be just as spectacular! ☺😄🤗
—Craftmomy on March 15, 2017Definitely throw in a few surprises! It adds to the fun.
—Barbara B. on March 15, 2017I’d choose B but would include some other color choices as well. The book looks wonderful–can’t wait to see it in the stores.
—Gale W. S. on March 15, 2017a) it is hard to improve on a perfect quilt. I love the color combination.
—Connie on March 15, 2017I think I would like the blue, black, red and double pink, but I also may try making another one with more modern fabrics.
—Marlene Wittmann on March 15, 2017I would go with A. I am just beyond being a newbie quilter and have not made anything related to the older fabrics. This would be a fun learning experience.
—Norma on March 15, 2017b. I would follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises from my stash.
—Karen McSparren on March 15, 2017It’s such a stunning quilt, I’d go with what the original makers intended. I think the grey background gives it a somewhat modern look already. But I’d also like to try it with modern fabrics. Thanks for a chance to win this great book and lovely fabrics!
—Judy W. on March 15, 2017c. I will use modern fabric
—Nancy on March 15, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Georgina on March 15, 2017I think I’d go with B. I would like to dig into some of the smaller pieces in my stash, and these blocks look like they would work perfectly with bits and pieces.
—Penny on March 15, 2017Love the colors chosen but may change it up to pastels and see what happens
—Esther on March 15, 2017I’d go with B, I just can’t stick to the plan, I always have to "adjust" something. The book looks amazing. thanks
—Mom C on March 15, 2017I think this would look great in more modern fabrics. Bright and cheerful.
—Sue on March 15, 2017I’d opt for "b" – throwing in a few other colors, probably some browns & greens.
—Stephanie S. on March 15, 2017Thanks!
I would follow the guidelines but I have so many scraps that I feel it necessary to use them and throw in surprises!
—Mary O on March 15, 2017B,I’d mix in some surprises.
—Marijo on March 15, 2017It’s a beautiful quilt! I love repro fabrics, so that is likely what I will do. My favorite block is the log cabin. It’s rich history & the scrappy looks you get with it are endless!
—Sharon Ernst on March 15, 2017Decidedly A! Those colors have a special meaning to these blocks in particular – of course just to be cantankerous I’d probably sneak a surprise in somewhere!
—Anne Manly on March 15, 2017I would be so eager to get started that I would use fabrics from my stash. In fact, I have already made four blocks…two from Civil War reproductions and two from my brightly colored fabrics. I have to get the book soon….looks as if I have started TWO QUILTS ALREADY,
—M. Elaine on March 15, 2017I would follow the fabric guide but throw in some civil war tans and browns too….
—Joni Giancola on March 15, 2017I would use the colors indicated, but put in some colors of my own because I have so many scraps that need to be used up. ( to make room for more.)
—Jean Jacobs on March 15, 2017I’d choose my own colors to complement the environment in which the quilt would be used.
—betty nelson on March 15, 2017I would use the colors indicated, but put in some colors of my own because I have so many scraps that need to be used up. ( to make room for more.) So B would be my choice.
—Jean Jacobs on March 15, 2017I would go with A, I love the look of the blue, black, red and double pink. It just seems to suit the quilt.
—Myra Sattler on March 15, 2017I would probably go with B. I like a surprise now and then!
—Diana R on March 15, 2017B. I love the colour suggestions, but those little surprise additions make the Quilts my own.
—Nina Bate on March 15, 2017I love traditional blocks and colors so would go with "a".
—Joyce on March 15, 2017To answer your question….I would go with b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I LOVE Civil War Quilts, in fact, I am working on one that I started at my LQS that was suppose to be a Beginner class. Ha, ha. Nope, it was more of an Intermediate to Advanced class. I hung in there for the year that it took, but most of my blocks are either half done or only cut out. I used lots of browns, golds, deep red colors, but then decided to lighten it up with some lavender and pinks. LOL. It will someday get finished and go on my King sized bed, but until then I would love to make some smaller blocks for a lap quilt or even a baby quilt. This book and these fabrics would be FABULOUS for that. So in ending, I’m keeping my fingers crossed and chanting…Pick Me, Pick Me, Pick Me. 🙂
—Sandra Caulder on March 15, 2017I love the original colors of red, pink, black & blue but I may throw in a brown here & there. I’m also going to make a second block out of modern fabrics. What fun would that be. Cant wait to get the book & the added bonus of fabrics would be wonderful!! Love the size of the blocks
—Leslie Rozum on March 15, 2017I would fallow the colors but like B throw in a surprise. Beautiful Quilt.
—elr on March 15, 2017I would use greens/browns/reds/golds to match my decor.
—Mim Case on March 15, 2017I would go with Civil War inspired fabrics. So probably more ‘a’. The fabrics and book look great!
—Marie on March 15, 2017B. Would follow colors and add in some of my stash. I love civil war prints and would look forward to trying out these blocks.
—Kirsten on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colours intended. They are absolutely beautiful
—Teresa Fl on March 15, 2017I would go with what the makers intended with a few surprises thrown in.
—Sandy on March 15, 2017A) I would go with the original colors. I love the look of the quilt.
—Judy Maggio on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—susie on March 15, 2017Susie
C — I can already see some of these unusual blocks in my typical choices of bright hues and unlikely, but beautiful,color combinations.
—Candy Gawne on March 15, 2017I like the book very much, a lot of possibilities that it offers.
—Sheila Burgess on March 15, 2017I like the colors that are from the book, but I would choose Civil War prints.
I’d do it in red, white and blue. My favorite colors especially in reproduction fabric. Thank you for the chance to win.
—Carol Kuse on March 15, 2017I’d have to go with B – what’s a scrappy quilt without a few surprises? What a gorgeous new line and a very interesting book!
—Janet on March 15, 2017I’s go with blue,red, and white. Love these colors … would be very pretty for a vets. quilt….
—sandy on March 15, 2017I’d go with B. I think some burgundy fabrics might just go well with the rest.
—Terry on March 15, 2017I’d probably go with choice "a" which is so fresh looking and yet so traditional.
—Rosemary on March 15, 2017I would go with A–I love these fabrics for this project. Bring it on.
—Linda Blake on March 15, 2017I’d go with option "b." I like the traditional, but I would want to put my own spin on it!
—Christine Tanabe on March 15, 2017I would chose b and put in some fabric to make it personal.
—M stewart on March 15, 2017I would go with the Civil War prints but add a few zingers to make the quilt interesting.
—Linda on March 15, 2017I would follow the designers choices but throw in some ringers. I have a need to be a little rebellious. Lol
—Mandy Laseter on March 15, 2017I would have to go with "A"
—RoseMary Baty-Willcox on March 15, 2017Just love repo fabric.
Thank You for sharing.
I would love to win the book and fabrics to make the beautiful blocks. I would use the original colors. Thank you for the opportunity to win this wonderful book and fabrics.
—Cindy on March 15, 2017A .. would be my choice, having seen the colors, I fell in love with this. Fascinating … A new rendition of traditional blocks.
—barb h on March 15, 2017I’d pick B and be able to use a lot of my repro stash. So pretty!
—Nicole Worthington on March 15, 2017b: I would throw in some surprises!
—Nancy C on March 15, 2017I would have to go with B as I have enough reproduction prints to last me for several years.
—BECKY KLEIN on March 15, 2017Humm, I think B. I love a quilt that has unexpected twists. Although I have come to appreciate more modern fabrics, I am easing myself into actually using them! I like the idea of a rectangular block shape.
—Linda Voltz on March 15, 2017I would do "b" using a similar color way with a few surprises thrown in.
—Evelyn McCarthy on March 15, 2017I love Civil War era quilts. This just inspired me to use up my scraps.
—Ann Robbins on March 15, 2017I would make blocks using the original colors. Love Judies fabs have them all and many Carols books in my library.
—Minnette Cummins on March 15, 2017I kinda like B …..love little suprize’s … happyness04431@yahoo.com
—Anna brown on March 15, 2017I’d probably choose B, follow the color guide with a few surprises of my own choosing.
Since moving back to North Carolina a few years ago, I’ve wanted to do a period and location correct Civil War quilt for where I live.
—Sandy on March 15, 2017I would go with B. — spice it up a little bit.
—Ruth Roberts on March 15, 2017c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
—Judy Burks on March 15, 2017I’d go with A.
—Ann Austin on March 15, 2017I don’t think they could improve on the original ones.
A… I love it just the way the cover of the book shows! Red, blue, pink and black in a quilt always catches my eye 🙂
—Leanne Mal on March 15, 2017I would go with A. I would try to replicate the original quilt.
—Diane P. on March 15, 2017I would probably go with B. I love browns and greens and have lots available.
—Ellen Janssen on March 15, 2017Wow there seems to be a whole Jeneration of Judys commenting on this…what fun. I think I would like to experiment with colors and see what clear and bright combos I could come up with.
—Judy B on March 15, 2017I would use color guide but throw in a few surprises
—Pam on March 15, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Dorothy Livernash on March 15, 2017I would definitely love to make this one in the Civil War era fabrics, my all time faves. Looks like one fabulous new book!
—Melanie on March 15, 2017I would use the suggested fabrics with a few surprises. I do like the reproduction fabrics.
—Debra Ryan on March 15, 2017I’d go with the designers choices. I love the color combination.
—Judy on March 15, 2017I would use all scraps and whatever kind they happen to be so it could have modern, thirties reproductions, traditional, juvenile and more … bold and bright, or subtle could happen .. it would just be fun.
—Tonie Peterson on March 15, 2017My answer would be B
—Hilda Krebs on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colors because I love the Civil War era quilts.
—Vicki Krausz on March 15, 2017I think I’d use the warm colors of your typical flannel fabrics: rich browns, creams, cranberry, blueberry, etc.
—Jodie S on March 15, 2017Definitely A. I love reproduction fabrics.
—Debbie Nicholson on March 15, 2017I’d either use the new fabric line or use red, white, and blue, reproduction style!
—Karen Seitz on March 15, 2017I would go with A: the original color scheme- really like the look of that quilt!!
—Karen H on March 15, 2017B, follow the guide with a few surprises
—Sandi Kelly on March 15, 2017I love the original colours. 🙂
—Nita on March 15, 2017b) as maybe I don’t have all the original colors and why not add a little of your touch. Love Marcus fabrics!
—Tanya on March 15, 2017I would do A as i love the look! thanks!
—Lee on March 15, 2017I am so ready to make some 4×5 blocks. Not really into repro pinks but I have oodles of tans, beige & brown repro fabrics as well as some green & blue scraps leftover from 2 quilts that look repro. This book will have to be added to my library whether I win it or not!
—Joy on March 15, 2017I would go with the colors in the book but I would have to stock up on the pinks since that’s a little out of the box for me . I love the idea of 4X5 blocks!
—Mary Jean Price on March 15, 2017It’s Not a Square sounds like the book for me! I would use the original idea of colors and maybe different shades of those colors. The small sizes and different blocks make it easier for me to keep interest in a quilt. I like a challenge. Thanks you ladies for putting this all together in The 4″ x 5″ Quilt-Block Anthology.
—Carol Mina on March 15, 2017I would go with b. I do love a but need to make it my own. I love any churn dash block!
—Deena DeWall on March 15, 2017I would go C, modern…batiks.
—Melody Lutz on March 15, 2017I would go with b because I love reproduction fabrics and would want to use as many different fabrics as I could.
—Dottie Alexander on March 15, 2017I love repos but would have to stock up on some Browns and pinks. I would add in variations of colour as I’m a blue girl at heart with. Love the book
—Sandy Jones on March 15, 2017C – I would use modern fabrics because that’s mostly what I have in my fabric stash.
—MoeWest on March 15, 2017These blocks would be fun in any color combination!
—Gwen Wehner on March 15, 2017I’d go with A the first time!!!
—Marsha on March 15, 2017b – follow the guide but throw in some surprises
—Kirsten on March 15, 2017c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
—chris z on March 15, 2017I would use the original colors, except substitute navy for the black.
—wilma searcy on March 15, 2017I would go with option (a) simply because I have so many of these fabrics in my stash over years of collecting. I also think it would be wonderful in new modern colors and patterns. Thanks for a chance to win, such an incredible treat.
—Rita Nichols on March 15, 2017Love the book and the Fabric! I would choose B I have some wonderful reproductions that I cold add to the collection. I love your story except I’m sorry for the loss of your friend Linda. The thing about quilts is what a wonderful way to remember your friend and the time you shared together.
—Diana Lentz on March 15, 2017So excited to read about this new book, new style blocks and of course my favorite , civil war fabrics, and all on my birthday. Very nice present. Can wait to order this new book. I will probably follow the suggested colors. Sounds totally awesome to me. Thank you so much for this new adventure. Pierrette Marsh.
—Pierrette Marsh on March 15, 2017Definitely A, I love the color choices. I can’t wait to get the book. Thanks for all the hard work you guys did in putting the book together.
—Tammy on March 15, 2017What a great book! I would do it in purple, blue, and green batiks! My signature colors!
—Danette Roundy on March 15, 2017For me, a), I’d definitely go with the original. At least for the first quilt. As I think about it though, it would be fun to see how it might look in a different color scheme.
—Linda M on March 15, 2017I find my go to colors are reds, pinks, blues. Have been drawn to this book since your first sneak peak. I am glad to be informed early so I can get this book and plan to buy the American Swatch Book fabric this summer. Thanks mw
—marywallis soetebier on March 15, 2017I would start with the originals, but do b too, as I also have a large "oldies" stash. The challenge of the 4 x 5 block sounds like a new trend. And the block designers have already done the hard work. Kathy in colo
—kathy pfaltzgraff on March 15, 2017I would love to do this quilt in reds/creams leaning toward caramel. Love this interesting blocks and their unique size!
—Bonnie B on March 15, 2017I’m definitely a B. I’ve so much stash that I need to throw in a lot of "surprises."
—Judy Purcell on March 15, 2017I would leave the colors but make a second one with different materials. The book looks nice.
—Traci Anthony on March 15, 2017I’d make it using option b but I would also love to make it in reproduction fabrics in a completely different colourway – possibly using autumnal colours.
—Nannynette on March 15, 2017B of course, because I just can’t resist tweaking recipes & patterns!
—Marsha Ransom on March 15, 2017I would love to make it a #A in the same colors butnot having enough of Repos-I would have to go with doing C in Batiks, those I have!
—Jill Meador on March 15, 2017I would go with b. Probably switch some of the colors with burgundy, green, gold, brown and tan. Love reproduction patterns and fabrics!
—Lois Cave on March 15, 2017B) go with color guide with a couple surprises from my stash! Love the Marcus reproduction fabrics.
—Brenda on March 15, 2017I love the scrappy look of my collection of reproduction fabrics. I love a challenge of the 4 by 5 blocks. I would love this project.
—Connie Cameron on March 15, 2017What fun! I love the rectangle instead of a square. I would probably go B or C, depending on my stash.
—Maryellen on March 15, 2017Love Civil War quilts & fabric, so A would be my choice. I like the different spin on the blocks. Makes for great conversation with my quilting friends.
—Jude Sherman on March 15, 2017I would go with a. because I really love how those colors go together. Thank you.
—Linda Taylor on March 15, 2017I would definitely use the pink, double pink, blue, black colors.
—Bonnie on March 15, 2017I love this quilt! The blocks are different and challenging. I would stick with the colour line of the original and throw in a few surprises! (B). Winning the book and bundle would be a thrill!
—Tracy on March 15, 2017I would pick B as I would have to add some yellow, cheddar, green, and pink to perk it up a bit.
—Susan K. on March 15, 2017I think b would be me – always making little changes to personalise my work
—Kerry Grose on March 15, 2017Love the rectangular block format! While I feel the quilt would be stunning in many different palettes, I would love to see it created with solids for a graphic modern interpretation. I belong to both traditional and modern quilt guilds and this design would be gorgeous in so many different palettes. Keeping my fingers crossed that I get chosen for this giveaway.
—Debbie G on March 15, 2017Definately follow the colour guide. I am not always confident of my colour choices
—Vicki williams on March 15, 2017I would go with "A"…love the colors & prints in the Original quilt. Thank you for chance to win your Give-a-way too! 🙂
—Lori Morton on March 15, 2017Love the book and the pictures of the blocks and quilts. I think I would use use the basic colors suggested, but use different shade of the colors. Thanks for the chance to win the book and the fabrics.
—Vickie Keith on March 15, 2017Gosh, what a tough choice! I absolutely love the original reproduction fabrics, but it would be fun to try the blocks in other prints, I can see this quilt in autumn colors as well.
—Shelley Needham on March 15, 2017b)I would follow the guide with a few surprises. Thanks for the opportunity to win the fabric.
—Teresa on March 15, 2017I love my reproduction fabrics and would love to add to the stash. It would be fun to follow their color palette especially if I win the fabric bundle.
—Shellie on March 15, 2017b)I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises. I’d love to try the 4″x 5″ blocks.
—Nicole Sender on March 15, 2017I would go with the original colour scheme – the quilt is fabulous and the book looks great too.
—Pauline Perry on March 15, 2017I would be option B. I have a tiny sewing budget so I start all projects by raiding my stash. These blocks look like fun in any color.
—Chrysa H on March 15, 2017Of course I’ll follow Judie’s color way, but not without a few surprises from my reproduction shelf. I can’t wait to preview this new book of 4″x5″ blocks. What a novel but simple idea! The reason I love quilting…. Just when I think I’ve seen everything, along comes a new pattern, design, technique, or brilliant idea such as non-square blocks! Outstanding!! Thank you Carol, Linda & Judie.
—Marianne on March 15, 2017I would go with the original collection, haven’t made a quilt in these colors but would be open to other colors but not to take over the look of the quilt. It would be an interesting process.
—Althea Klosterman on March 15, 2017I would use modern colors and designs in the blocks. As my treatment for PTSD has progressed, I’m finding bright colors more and more attractive. So many of these blocks would look wonderful in bright, sunny colors and patterns, especially while helping to hold the darkness at bay. I’ve wanted to start quilting for a long time, and this would be the perfect way to get started.
—Kzoo Kid on March 15, 2017I think I would go with the original fabrics, plus greens, browns, and cheddars, still Civil War era styled fabrics, but a wider variety of colors. Very original block ideas!!!
—Amanda Best on March 15, 2017I love the chosen colors, but it would be fun to add some surprises to make a quilt truly unique! Can’t wait to see this book!
—Dixie Klima on March 15, 2017All great choices, but I would go with B
—Sharon on March 15, 2017I would definitely go with B. Love the colors of Civil War Era, however throwing in a little of today would be unexpected fun.
—Delia Gomez on March 15, 2017I would take option b: I just recently learned to use purples and I would defeinetely use some of those too. And a few yellow surprises…
—Sandra Robben on March 15, 2017I love the colors in the original.They are so muted.I love civil war fabrics so much that there all I buy anymore!
—peggy kanz on March 15, 2017I like the original colors but I would do something different and go bright. Why not?
—Chris on March 15, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises, such as exchanging the pink for other blues.
—Rhonda Best on March 15, 2017I enjoyed reading the story behind the quilt and think the 4″x 5″ blocks would be fun to make. I probably would follow the color guide and throw in some surprises.
—Judy on March 15, 2017I would go with the red,white and blue-simply because that’a a new colorscheme for me! I always tend to go with the brown antique look…..
—Berit W. Moe on March 15, 2017What a wonderful looking book. The quilts are beautiful. "B" is my choice. I love the colors used, but i would have to add used
—Sharron Pyle on March 15, 2017What a wonderful looking book. The quilts are beautiful. "B" is my choice. I love the colors used, but I would have to add a few of my own "loves" to make it mine! I have a full stash of historical reproductions so this quilt really fascinates me!
—Sharron Pyle on March 15, 2017I would go with b.
—Sigrun Schmidt on March 16, 2017I love the original colours – but it would be great to have some surprises.
—Susanne on March 16, 2017B. I love the original colours, but would throw in a few Om my own. 4 x 5 is such a different concept from all squares.
—Cheryl Noakes on March 16, 2017I’d go with c, the modern fabrics. I love the blocks, particularly as a handwork project and I think the quilt would look just as stunning in more vibrant colours – dark to light hued blues with a jade accent, purples with touches of yellow or even a range of taupes with multiple accents making a rainbow quilt
—Maggie Marlow on March 16, 2017I would go with b. I think it would make for an interesting quilt
—Janice L. on March 16, 2017I would go with a what beautiful fabrics why spoil perfection it’s such a beautiful quilt.
—Patricia Such on March 16, 2017I’d follow the color guide,but throw in some twists depending what fabrics were in my stash. It would make a unique quilt.
—Karen on March 16, 2017I would use the fabrics made for the book…I use reproduction fabrics now for quilt blocks in that size and can’t wait to have new ones!!!!!
—Betty Purdes on March 16, 2017I would do (b). Love the colors in this quilt but I have a stash that I’d like to add in with it also.
—Glenda Tron on March 16, 2017I think I’d go with the originals. Beautiful fabric!
—Allison Evrard on March 16, 2017Definitely the repo fabrics, after all isn’t this what the book is about. Love the fact that the blocks are 4 x 5″. They seem like a good size for using scraps on, which I think were mainly used during this era.
—Diane Russell on March 16, 2017I don’t have many Civil War repros, so my answer is C, I would go a different direction. Great looking blocks and quilts–this book is definitely a winner!
—Julie in GA on March 16, 2017I would do B. This looks like a great book. Love the fabrics!
—Charlene Federowicz on March 16, 2017I would mostly stick with the original colors but I think a few dark yellow’s would add something.
—Diana Collins on March 16, 2017I would go with (a) as much as I could, but my stash isn’t that big so I may have to change one or two. Thanks for the giveaway.
—Sunnybec on March 16, 2017I love these blocks and love the color choices in the book! I think I would stick with reds, grays and black.
—Diane on March 16, 2017Definitely B, but with a few surprises!
—Ginger Marshall on March 16, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
I’m all about modern, bright colors, but the quilt shown looked so beautiful. It would be nice to have a quilt that looked traditional.
—Judy on March 16, 2017B. I like to personalize it with a few fabrics from my stash – though the fabrics are ‘delicious’!
—Diane Livezey on March 16, 2017B would be my choice because I love to add a bit from my stash.
—Theresa Westrup on March 16, 2017I’d go with the original color palette. but it might be nice in beige. pink and chocolate with a dash of aqua.
—Anne Werner on March 16, 2017I would have to choose a) – I would stick with the colors they picked out which I LOVE! Thank you!
—Erin Earl on March 16, 2017All of the above?? I have a collection of vintage fabrics, that go well with some reproductions.. I *love* the "long block" idea!
—Carol Kuntz on March 16, 2017i would like to try it with the suggested fabrics, but I would also make a second of each block in Asian style fabrics to match my bedroom.
—Lucy Brown on March 16, 2017A and C. I would probably try at least some of them in the modern fabrics just to see what they would look like. Then for sure I would make them in the original A fabrics. thank you for a chance to win this wonderful book and fabric.
—Marge buck on March 16, 2017b) – because I like the reproduction fabrics, but like to add a few "out-of-the-box" colors for a little pizzaz.
Thanks for sharing this – it looks like a terrific book to share with quilty friends and start your own challenge.
Take care!
—Elaine Sweitzer on March 16, 2017Elaine
Would love to win this book and collection. Love the shape and Judie Rothermel has always been my faborite. Would pick B and use some of my stash. Gorgeous! Thank you for the inspiration.
—Bonney Burack on March 16, 2017a) I would go with what the original makers intended.
—Kaye Walker on March 16, 2017The color guide would be a help but i would give it my own creative touch.
—Tasneem on March 16, 2017Thank you.
I would use traditional civil war fabrics for the most part, yet there has to be an outlier or tow!
—Carol white on March 16, 2017I would try using colors RED, WHITE and BLUE!
—Donna H. on March 16, 2017I would keep with red, black and gray color choices to enhance my craft area. This is a great collection of patterns!
—Sharon on March 16, 2017I love the reproduction fabrics – but I don’t really have any. I don’t know why, because I just love this "new movement!" The history behind our hobby is inspiring to me. It would be fun to make this on my great-grandmother’s treadle machine…. Now that would provide a new appreciation for technology!
—Sara on March 16, 2017B – I’d mainly go with the color palette but deviate a bit
—Lynn D in NC on March 16, 2017I love the design and will make it mainly in batiks so I pick C.
—Margaret Andolshek on March 16, 2017c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular! since I’m on a budget and can only use what I have on hand.
—Cathy on March 16, 2017I would love to go with the red blue black and double pinks but would also have to throw in some browns. Stunning! I Alison need to invest in more shirtings for the background piecing.
—Donna Rowe on March 16, 2017A. I have a two stacks of repro fabrics just waiting–I’ve had trouble figuring out just how to use these precious pieces. I LOVE the colors used in the quilt and I think I’d learn a lot by following someone else’s color scheme.
—Lisa G Boyer on March 16, 2017I would select B…traditional patterns but I would put in an occasional different fabric choice. Nothing wild, mind you, but something to brighten up a block or two (or more!)
—Arlene Kilborn on March 16, 2017The colors used for the book blocks are my favorite colors so I would use those!
—Tamrey Davis on March 16, 2017I love the old civil war patterns and the repo fabrics. I would stay with the design fabric with a little twist of my touch. Sew it would be ‘B’
—kathy on March 16, 2017I would start with A but probably throw a few B in there. Love the Civil War Era quilts. In a Civil War Sewing Circle group and we are always looking for fun, new patterns. This book would be wonderful. Thanks for the chance to win
—connie b on March 16, 2017C – I’d like to try them with a modern spin!
—Ali on March 16, 2017I would love to use the reproduction color palette. I love those colors and the history behind the quilt blocks.
—Lynette on March 16, 2017I would go with the original colors – they are spectacular! Thanks!
—Delaine on March 16, 2017When I am trying a new pattern I go with traditional. I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Kathleen on March 16, 2017I would make the blocks using a. I love reproduction fabrics and these fabrics would make a beautiful quilt. A lovely color selection.
—Rita Trumbull on March 16, 2017I’d go with option "B" – I like the traditional look, but expanded a bit!
—Pam on March 16, 2017a) I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Gwendolyn Clark on March 16, 2017I would make these blocks in modern fabrics.
—Karen Hootman on March 16, 2017Have to be a "B" girl. All good intentions, etc….
—Patricia Hersl on March 16, 2017I’d go with the original colors! I like the restful look of the quilt on the cover.
—Sue S on March 16, 2017c) I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics—the quilts would be just as spectacular!
I’m really into blues and browns right now. Add a little cream and it would all be delish!
—Jo Haraf on March 16, 2017Love the idea of 4″ & 5″ blocks. A great way to use my scrapes! I really like the reproduction fabrics.
—Elaine on March 16, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide and throw in a few surprises!!!
—Diane H. on March 16, 2017Since I’m a novice quilter I would use the fabrics as they appear in the blocks from the book, but once I get more experience and feel more confidence I would love to add a splash of color to see how it looks!
—Lynn Thornton on March 16, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Karen on March 16, 2017Original colors–so pretty!
—Lill on March 16, 2017I would probably do B.
—Judith Martinez on March 16, 2017I want to go with the original colors, but I think a little cheddar would be a good zinger if used sparingly. I have the 4 x 5 anthology on my wishlist. But the BOM with the fabric would be fun to do
—Mary on March 16, 2017I would go with the original colors and add to match.
—Jennifer Huntly on March 16, 2017I am anxious to get my book, I looked at a friends and waiting for mine to arrive.
I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Lesley on March 16, 2017I choose "B." I love a few surprises in my quilts!
—Kristi on March 16, 2017No modern colors for me. I like colonial colors, scrappiness and antebellum coloring.
—Debbie Mahlberg on March 16, 2017I would most likely follow the original guidelines with a surprise or two thrown in. What would be even more fun for me would to have two parallel sets going – one in a traditional color way, one with a brighter more modern palette. What fun!
—Heather on March 16, 2017I love the book and fabrics. If I were to win, I would make lots of red and white blocks. Red is my favorite color. Please enter me in the drawing.
—Eleanor K Hunzinger on March 16, 2017b-I always change up something on any quilt that I make. Beautiful quilt & fabric. Thanks for presenting this info & chance to win.
—Sandie G on March 16, 2017Love the idea of 4×5 blocks, this looks like a great book with so many possibilities. If I won the fabrics I would make a throw or baby blanket with them so an A but then I would go crazy trying out blocks from the book in different fabrics
—nina on March 16, 2017Defintely a – the colors are just right.
—Jean Mosley on March 17, 2017This is going to be an interesting new adventure. I would go with the double pink, red, black and blue. I do wonder about the black as it is not much used in repro.
—Susie Q on March 17, 2017Vintage but more than that. And plenty of blocks to choose favorites from.
—chris on March 17, 2017I like it!
I love anything that will help me create a red white and blue quilt. This would be stunning, however, I would love to do this in the vintage colors and at the same time I do those blocks I would make the blocks from my stash. My stash is only 2 years old so modern colors. It would be fun.
—Vicki Schmidt on March 17, 2017I have begun using my 1800s repro fabrics and I notice I don’t have much red or black in them, but I have lots of browns, which look great with the pinks. So I guess I’d have to include the browns. Love these!
—Joye on March 17, 2017I have been working with the color wheel and trying to be more adventurous, so would probably pick blue as my main color and go from there. Looks like such a great book with some wonderful block ideas. Thank you for this giveaway opportunity. It’s wonderful to have designer’s like Carol and Linda who add so much to the quilting world!
—Vicki L on March 17, 2017I would do many blocks the way they are shown but, with all the reproduction fabric I have saved over the years, I would incorporate those in other blocks. Love repros and this book!
—Marge on March 17, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Sheila on March 17, 2017I would probably choose option A. I am very into the civil war patterns & colors right now. Can’t seem to get enough. It would be fun to try some bright colors also.
—Kandy Krieser on March 17, 2017I just know that if you pick me, it will make my "civil war" heart flutter!!
I would use those wonderful original colors!
—Linda Haan on March 17, 2017I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises
—Susan Reeder on March 17, 2017I think I would definitely be a c). I’m a new quilter and I am so enthralled with all the new modern fabrics.
—Ruth Bradford on March 17, 2017I would start with 20’s and 30’s fabrics and add my own twist by adding older fabrics to give it a "scrap bag" feel. I love the layout!
—Cheri Bergeron on March 17, 2017I’d go with what the original makers intended: blue, black, red, and double pink.
—Christine M on March 17, 2017oh how i love these fabrics!!!!! i adore these little blocks….i can’t wait for the book….this is one contest i really hope i win! janet
—janet on March 17, 2017My choice would be a). Agree with others to honor Linda’s
—Marta on March 17, 2017brainstorm idea brought to fruition with original colors.
I would chose "b" as I also love the pinks, browns and medium blues that are civil war colors. Plus I already have quite a collection, but would love, love, love to win more!
—Linda S. on March 17, 2017C–I’d like to see it in modern fabrics, although I do love the reproduction fabrics, too!
—Kris B on March 17, 2017I would study the color guide and determine where I could improvise with my extensive stash of scraps.
—Barbaraben on March 17, 2017I would definitely stick with the original color scheme for the first quilt made with these blocks-those are my three favorite colors-blue, black and red!
—Debbie Miller on March 17, 2017Count me in! I’d probably be a (b).
—Carol K on March 17, 2017B. Needs a few greens.
—Judy B on March 17, 2017I would opt for "B" so I could use up some orphan fabrics.
—Rosalind Gutierrez on March 17, 2017D) none of the above. I would dig into my scraps!
—Sandy Curtis on March 17, 2017I would say "B" I like the original colors, but I’d probably add a few of my own.
—Mary on March 17, 2017I would follow along as the author/designer intended and then just maybe throw in a few surprises.
—Sue Smith on March 17, 2017B.
—Barbara Macey on March 17, 2017I’ve never used any retro fabrics before & have decided to give this a try. I would throw in a few "purples" with the reds to make it pop for me.
I would stay with the chosen fabrics for it, I love how they look.
—Irene Cole on March 17, 2017I love repro fabrics and would use those first. Then I’d play with modern fabrics, or simply raid my stash at random!
—Diane R Callahan on March 17, 2017I have recently fallen in love with repro fabrics after a quilt in a catalog caught my eye and I ordered the fat quarter bundle it was made with. I always thought of repro fabrics as kind of dark and dismal, but these are so bright and vibrant, in blues, reds, pinks, white shirting, and a little gold. Beautiful! So I would probably be a b) and change things up a bit. Love the look of these blocks.
—Kathleen T on March 17, 2017Make it modern– with a nod to the traditional.
—Marcia on March 17, 2017I would go with the original colors.
—Joan on March 17, 2017I think the original colors in the book. Love the way they look.
—Christine Charlebois on March 17, 2017I would go with A. So vintage!
—Heather Beckett on March 17, 2017LOVE the 4″ x 5″ block idea! I’m always amazed at the creatativity
—Kathy on March 17, 2017of quilters, and Judy’s fabrics are always a TREAT. I would say I’d be an A
but would see what I have of Judy’s on hand to perhaps add to her
collection. (Adding something from my limited, not knowing what I’d use
it for stash always makes me happy. Like I finally got it.) LOL
I would go with colors as close to the original as possible first, then maybe try some other colorways. I have some inherited fabrics that are pretty close to some of those shown.I have been saving them for something spectacular, but would of course have to use some newer fabrics as I don’t have all those colors shown.
—Cynthia I Maki on March 17, 2017Love the fabric and the book looks fantastic! I would go with "B" – original colors with a little pop thrown in. Thanks
—Donna W on March 17, 2017I’d go with B.
—Elaine on March 17, 2017I think I’d go with B and add a few fabrics from my own stash.
—Brenda on March 17, 2017I think I would use Civil War reproduction fabrics and probably use the original color combination.
—Nancy A on March 17, 2017I would use the fabric recommended and throw in a few of my own. I love repo fabrics and have many in my own stash.
—Cindy Kahrs on March 17, 2017A! With such a great book I would do it in the most traditional way it’s possible
—Camillo on March 17, 2017I would do B
—Joanna on March 17, 2017I love the fabrics and the quilt that was on the cover, but as I usually do, I would probably add a few other colors or use different colors for some of the blocks & sashing.
—John Scibran on March 17, 2017I believe I would go with the original color choices. I made one civil war quilt and used the exact fabrics shown in the pattern and loved it. It was a gift to my son-in-law who is a history buff.
—Gladys Bacon-Rust on March 17, 2017I would probably follow the original colorway.
—Tac on March 17, 2017First one would be with the original colors and the second would be brights.
—Jeanmarie K on March 17, 2017I would have to say a.) the original color combination. I have been collecting different material & patterns to make a Civil War quilt. Winning this would be the push to finally make one. Thanks for the chance to win this wondrous book & fabric.
—Genevieve C on March 17, 2017I love the colors the makers chose but also enjoy the option of throwing in a surprise of another fabric I might like. Excited about the book. Looks great!!!
—Rilla Burnham on March 17, 2017I would follow the guide but use lots of my CW fabric and reproduction fabrics!
—Stella Blunt on March 17, 2017I think I’d a be a (b) and throw in a few surprises! Thanks for the chance to win 🙂
—Debby E on March 17, 2017B or C. Lol its hard to stick with the rules. Fingers crossed.
—Joanne Roberts on March 17, 2017B; I always use some other colors in my projects.
—Anna on March 17, 2017I’d use the given fabrics. I lean toward strong contrasts and colors, and I love these muted tones. I’d like to try that, and this would keep me in line!
—Sandy on March 17, 2017I’d go with Plan B, and add some warmer colors, I think. I have a big stash and would be pulling from there. Love this book and the non-square design.
—Beth T. on March 17, 2017I would use a piece of every repro fabric I have. Lots of different colors. Can’t wait to try some of these blocks.
—Ann Holland on March 17, 2017I think I would be guided by the original colors for the most part but I would probably throw in some ideas of my own.
—carol on March 17, 2017I would choose A. I’m still a newbie, and like to know what it will turn out like!
—Piroska on March 17, 2017I have a stash of CW repro that has been calling my name; I think this is it !! Would love to win and let them come out of the closet. Thanx for the chance!
—Deanna Davis on March 17, 2017I love the colors they picked but would have to add in a few others from my stash!
—Cathy Wilson on March 17, 2017I am a "dyed in the wool" repro girl but recently have been bitten by the modern bug! My initial response when I saw the cover was that it felt "modern" to me. So I’m planning on a grey background blended with conservative modern (if there is such a thing) and those beautiful fat quarters! I’ll have to play with the blocks, but I can’t wait!!
—Pam C on March 17, 2017Wow, what a story. I would choose A. Those would not be my choices as they are not in my stash, but I do love them…maybe I will convert to be a repro lover. I do love shirtings.
—Rosalie on March 17, 2017This sounds like great fun! My choice is B. I would consider the suggested colors but would throw in some zingers to make my quilt unique!!
—JLouise on March 17, 2017I’d love to sew these blocks in modern fabrics. I think the blocks would be amazing!
—Linda Webster on March 17, 2017I’ve got a pretty fair collection of civil war reproduction fabrics, FQs, yardage, and tiny scraps… bet-cha I could make the whole collection without buying a pinch of new fabric. But there’s always room for more in the bin.
—Kay on March 17, 2017B & C
—Robin J on March 17, 2017I’d try these blocks in modern fabrics — but throw in a few surprises!
I would use the historic colors. Like them the best!
—Mary AnnMcClure on March 17, 2017I’d choose A — the original color choices (not to mentions Judie’s gorgeous new line) are just perfect!
—Katherine on March 17, 2017I would use the same colors as what the pattern in shown using. Thanks for the giveaway.
—Renea Yarolim on March 17, 2017C. I’d love to see these in modern spring fabrics
—Kim on March 17, 2017I would use the color guide but would throw in some new colors as a surprise (B). Both sides of my family had civil war era quilters from both sides of the Mason Dixon line. The love of quilting has been passed down through each generation.
—Jeanne on March 17, 2017I would have to go with the original colors for the first quilt then try others!
—Bridget on March 17, 2017B). I would have to add some exciting color to make it pop-maybe cheddar or green.
—Louise Mease on March 17, 2017I like the original colors they picked! The book looks great!
—Chris on March 17, 2017i would choose B and use my repro stash and throw in a surprise or two thanks for the opportunity to enter
—irene indelicato on March 17, 2017I am "b"
—Linda Christianson on March 17, 2017I love new ideas and have lots of cw scraps so would use from my stash and add some of the new fabric prints too. Can’t wait to see the new book!!!
—Linda Willen Willen on March 17, 2017B–I always like to throw in my own ideas.
—Tina on March 17, 2017I would do C.
—Terri S on March 17, 2017I’d use the original colors – I love them!
—Patricia Ludwiczak on March 17, 2017I would have to go with B. I love the red, blue, black, double pinks and shirtings but would have to substitute a zinger or two two plus a few green and purples. I’m not a big fan of the gray background so would audition other neutrals. I do think this would also be great in batiks or brights. Carol is a favorite of mine and I love Garnett’s setting. Can’t wait to start it.
—Barb Robinson on March 17, 2017I would go with the original color line☺
—Mary R on March 17, 2017Definitely I would go with B. What fun to make this quilt from the original colors but would like more variety in mine. I’m a scrappy quilter so a few fabrics just wouldn’t do.
—Cindy on March 17, 2017I usually start out following the suggestions, but somehow wind up doing something different along the way.
—bookboxer on March 17, 2017Well, I’d have to go with "C". as I have an abundance of material and really don’t need to add reproductions to the mix.
—shirley marvin on March 17, 2017(b) I would follow color guide but throw in some surprises
—Denise Campbell on March 18, 2017I would choose b and throw in a few surprises. I can’t wait to get this book.
—Kathleen King on March 18, 2017Wow what a twist…..I really like "A" but I think I would have to throw in at least one "B" for hidden surprise.
—Tamara Eaker on March 18, 2017I would choose b – I love the "old" look but would try to make it my own
—Elizabeth Tranberg on March 18, 2017I would choose b – I love the "old" look but would try to make it my own
—Elizabeth Tranberg on March 18, 2017—Elizabeth Tranberg on March 18, 2017
I would go modern! A good block design in ageless.
—Nancy N on March 18, 2017Just when you think there’s nothing new in quilting, a great idea like this pops up! I couldn’t choose between A and C. I guess I’d have to make two quilts.
—Barbara on March 18, 2017Love the original fabric choices and would maintain that theme.
—Lillian Klaeger on March 18, 2017Thank you for this wonderful, inspiring book. God bless you.
—Judy Gehardt on March 18, 2017I would definitely do A. Especially in the colors shown. I love civil war fabrics and the ones for this quilt is awesome.
—Stacey Mitchell on March 18, 2017Definitely A. I love red, white and blue reproduction fabrics and I would LOVE this book too!
—Renee Welton on March 18, 2017I would probably follow the colors of the original, but with a few more colors in the mix. Civil War reproductions are my favorite!
—Rebecca on March 18, 2017Actually, I’d be tempted to use 30’s repros. If I talked myself out of that plan, I’d do A.
—Nancy Eriksen on March 18, 2017I would choose all the above. Why limit myself to any one when I can make more than one quilt and try all color combinations . Civil war fabrics would be the first choice and then on from there. The book sounds like a great addition to my collection. Thank you for the great book!
—Linda Adams on March 18, 2017I think I’d go with the colors that are shown, though there may be times that a slight veer off the path is necessary! 🙂
—Elizabeth Tallau on March 18, 2017I would follow the original colors but throw in a few to mix it up. I like to add a personal touch to my projects. Love the book.
—Mary on March 18, 2017I would choose B…
b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Gina on March 18, 2017Love this quilt, but I’d probably do it in more modern fabrics!
—Janet on March 18, 2017I would follow the guide but throw in some surprises. I want to use up some of my stash. Thanks for the giveaway.
—Virginia Bronner on March 19, 2017I am a c. I would love to try these lovely blocks in modern fabrics. Thanks for the giveaway!
—Gloria Cotten on March 19, 2017i love the civil war fabrics and now i have something to look forward to doing with them. the blocks i really love i will probably make other quilts repeating blocks for a more modern style quilt, but i love the not square quilt look & i look forward to setting up to start my not square civil war quilt one block at a time. thank you for this wonderful opportunity
—susan on March 19, 2017I think I would try A. I love scrappy quilts and usually make my own color choices. But I love these blocks and the color way they chose, maybe I could stick with it for an entire quilt. It would be a new challenge for me!
—Rachel on March 19, 2017I love history and repro fabrics, so would do the blocks in civil war fabrics, but they come in other colours besides these, so I’d likely throw in a few surprises.
—Laura B on March 19, 2017I would definitely use my Jo Morton fabrics as I have quite a collection of them.
—Joyce O. on March 19, 2017I would use B as my guide but also use other Judie Rothermel civil war fabrics collected over time. Thank you for such a wonderful contest.
—Joan Wilson on March 19, 2017I have a collection of Civil War reproduction fabrics that are really beautiful. I would use a few surprise pieces to make it my own. The blocks are also a fun new project to start.
—Donna Philip on March 19, 2017I love the original colors but I would go with (b) and stitch in a few surprises too!!
—Cheryl on March 19, 2017I don’t have enough repro fabrics for a or b, so I would go with c. I might try it in all solids.
—LisaS on March 19, 2017I would love to use the Swatch Book colors–they are great!
—Barb K. on March 19, 2017b) I’d follow the color guide but throw in a few surprises.
—Alesha K Klein on March 19, 2017would love this!
—margaret mager on March 19, 2017I would probably do b using some of my own fabric.
—Polly Blank on March 20, 2017B – I’d follow the color guide but probably throw in a few surprises!
—Jackie Isler on March 20, 2017C. I would try modern fabrics. But, it might be interesting to make these blocks with small, medium, and large florals in pastels.
—Wilma Woods-Davis on March 20, 2017I’m more of a blue-green-purple-teal kinda gal, But I NEVER rule out any colour. I have used them all! And I have a special liking for plaid.
—JanG on March 21, 2017I just love the colors that they would have originally used … I guess I am a bit of a purist (or just old fashioned) …thanks
—Michele Meacham on March 22, 2017I would have to do modern colors
—Jeannette sroka on March 22, 2017Being new to quilting I think I’d follow the original and maybe toss in some surprises. Would love to win. Thank you
—Doreen Little on March 22, 2017I think the original colors are stunning, so I would stick with the original and I would love to win.
—Linda Garcia on March 22, 2017I would definitely use the perfect colors chosen for the book! I’ve gone with a few more modern quilts lately but am anxious to get back to my first love – reproductions!
—Judy Ashlock on March 22, 2017I love the repro fabrics and I use them whenever possible, so I guess I’d be an A. thanks for a fantastic giveaway.
—Holly on March 23, 2017I would probably stay in the original color way. I am a civil war fabric gal.
—Paulette Voit on March 23, 2017I have many OLD fabrics I’ve collected through my 68 yrs. They would be perfect in this quilt.
—sherry moses on March 23, 2017